I love going to the beach and to the pool – and I don’t just dip my toes in while I sit by the side. I actually splash in and play with friends and family. And one of the things I very much do not look forward to everytime I go swimming is running makeup. I really dread it when I come out of the water with streaks of colors going down the side of my face.
The best waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming is the L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer. It’s perfect for all-day wear without smudging or fading and it’s truly waterproof. The ultra fine tip also helps create natural looking brows.
Of course, everyone is different, so be sure to consider a few things in order to find the right eyebrow pencil for your eyes. For instance, options like which shades are available, does it have a built-in spoolie, and how long-lasting the formula will be. With these factors in mind, I review and summarize my current favorites below.
If you want to find out what made the cut according to these standards, go ahead and read along with me!
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | |
|---|---|---|
Editor's Choice  |
| View On Amazon →Read Our Review |
Runner-Up  |
| View On Amazon →Read Our Review |
 |
| View On Amazon →Read Our Review |
 |
| View On Amazon →Read Our Review |
 |
| View On Amazon →Read Our Review |
The Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil for Swimming
1. L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer – Our Pick!
Our number one pick for the best waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming is the L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer! A waterproof eyebrow pencil, this is sure to last on your brows for a very long time without smudging or budging even through swimming and a number of water activities you might engage in. This promises to stay put and keep your brow makeup intact as you enjoy leisure water activities with friends and family without fading of any sort. This also ensures that it stays in place through sweating, oil skin, and an active lifestyle.
Designed with an ultra-fine tip, this L’Oreal Paris eyebrow pencil is able to effectively recreate tiny brow hairs for a natural-looking pair of brows that’s sure to last for an entire day. You can trust this one to fill in sparse brows and gaps to give you a defined and filled-in appearance. The ultra-fine tip looks just like fine hairs so you are able to achieve a finish that looks like real brow hairs instead of the fake-looking solid block appearance as other eyebrow pencils would give you.
The Brow Stylist Definer brow pen comes with a built-in spoolie on the opposite end of the pencil to groom the brows and blend your final look. The spoolie also comes in very handy when you accidentally apply too much product and would need something to blend to still get a natural look. The formula of the eyebrow pencil is extremely easy to use and goes on much smoothly, allowing you to blend it well with your brows for that natural and untraceable finish. The pen itself is also fairly easy to control so you can achieve your desired look with comfort and ease.
An ophthalmologist-tested formula, this is very safe to use on sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses, without much fear of irritating the eyes.This is also a cheap option for those not yet willing to spend too much on a new eyebrow pencil. No worries though, as the affordable price will never compromise the quality and long-lasting formula you get with this one – the quality is so good and long-lasting that it withstands swimming and water activities!
The only downside a few users have reported on is how the tip of the brow pencil can be soft and can easily break off when too much pressure is used on application. To avoid the breakage of your pencil’s tip, make sure to handle it with care and apply with a gentle and soft hand. This is currently available in 10 shades you can conveniently choose from for all your makeup needs.
Pros:
- Waterproof formula with smudging or budging
- Stays put and intact even with swimming and water
- Ultra-fine tip recreates tiny hair brows
- Fills in gaps and sparse brows for a fuller look
- Great for achieving natural looks
- Built-in spoolie to groom brows and blend final look
- Easy to use, applies smoothly, and blends well
- Easy to control pen
- Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lenses wearers
- Inexpensive but good quality pencil
- Available in 10 shades
Cons:
- Tip can be soft and may break off easily
2. NYX Micro Brow Pencil – Best for Sparse Brows!
The next item on our list of the best waterproof eyebrow pencils for swimming and our top pick for the best for sparse brows is the Micro Brow Pencil from beauty brand NYX! If you have sparse brows and are looking for an eyebrow pencil that can efficiently fill your brows in for a fuller and a much defined look, you might want to check this one out. It has a super skinny tip that helps you draw extra-fine lines that can easily mimic the look of natural brow hairs. This effectively helps you fill in sparse areas for a fuller and defined finish.
If what you’re after are naturally-defined brows with sparse and over-tweezed areas completely filled in, this might be what you’re looking for. The pencil’s micro precise strokes easily coats even the finest hairs and allows you to achieve a very natural-looking finish. You can trust this one to shape and define your brows by filling in sparse areas that you can flaunt all day, every day. The fine tip allows you to draw defined but natural-looking eyes as it fills in areas that need filling in.
Though this NYX brow pencil doesn’t claim to be waterproof formulated, many users would beg to disagree as this will last on your brows without smudging and fading until you say it is time to go. You can also conveniently use this when you’re swimming and in water. This stays put and intact as you work out, sweat, swim, go under water, and maintain an active lifestyle. WIth this in your makeup routine, you are sure to never again get strains of color falling down along your face as it fades into nothingness.
NYX is proud to be cruelty-free and is officially PETA-certified. If that is something of major importance for you, you might want to consider this as your next eyebrow pencil for swimming. The consistency of the pencil is a good balance between stiffness and creaminess, allowing you to use and apply it with much ease and comfort against your skin. The waxy consistency also definitely helps the pencil achieve great longevity for an all-day wear even on water – whether you’re swimming or caught in the rain.
If what you’re hoping to achieve is a bold eyebrow finish, you might want to skip this as the pigment this gives isn’t too saturated – just the perfect level to achieve a more natural finish and look. This is currently available in a variety of 8 shades for all skin tones and hair colors.
Pros:
- Ideal for sparse brows
- Fills in sparse and over-tweezed areas for fuller looks
- Skinny tip allows for extra-fine lines
- Mimics the appearance of natural brow hairs
- Coats even the finest hairs
- Shapes and defines brows for a natural finish
- Stays on even through swimming and water
- No smudging and fading until you take it off
- Comes off easily
- Cruelty-free and PETA-certified
- Waxy consistency is easy to apply and last long
- Available in 8 shades
Cons:
- Pigment is not for strong and bold eyebrow looks
3. Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil – Best Splurge!
Our next favorite waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming and also our best splurge option is the Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil! If what you’re on the hunt for is a new swimming-proof eyebrow pencil you can splurge on, you might want to read on for this one. Boasting of a custom tip, this easily shapes, defines, and fills in your brows for natural and full-looking brows that will last you throughout the day! The goof-proof tip allows you to achieve soft color and an easy-glide on formula for ease and comfort.
A waterproof formula, this Benefit brow pencil lasts up to 12 hours and promises no smearing or smudging – even as you swim and engage in water activities! This is super long-lasting and will stay put even underwater, assuring that you will not get out of the water with fading brows. The waxy consistency of the pencil adds even more longevity factor so you won’t have to retouch throughout the day even as you lead an active lifestyle and consistently sweat.
WIth this Goof Proof eyebrow pencil, you are sure to achieve natural-looking brows that don’t look too fake or blocky at all – all you have to do is make sure to get the right shade! The easy glide-on formula of the pen allows for an easy and fast brow filling and shaping. This is very user-friendly as it allows for maximum control as you shape and define your brows for a fuller and accurate eyebrow results.
At the other end of this Benefit eyebrow pencil is a built-in spoolie brush you can conveniently use to blend your final look before you officially head out of the house. Aside from being easy to apply on your brow hairs, this is also very easy to correct when necessary. The spoolie comes in very handy when you need to correct mistakes during application. Overall, this promises to withstand sweating, hot weather, rain, and even swimming without ever fading, budging, or smearing all over your face.
A downside users have shared regarding this waterproof eyebrow pencil is that the tip can be quite soft and can break off easily, so make sure you handle and apply it with care so as not to break it off. Also keep in mind that this can be a bit more expensive than the rest of the items on our list but if you’re ready to splurge, go on right ahead. This is currently available in a variety of 12 shades for all your makeup needs!
Pros:
- Ideal splurge option
- 12-hour waterproof formula
- Withstands sweating, water, and swimming
- Stays put with smudging or smearing
- Shapes, defies, and fills in brows easily
- Built-in spoolie brush for blending
- Allows for natural-looking brows
- User-friendly with maximum control
- Easy to apply and correct where needed
- Available in 12 shades
Cons:
- Expensive
- Tip can be soft
4. Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
The Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil from beauty brand Maybelline New York is the next item that made it into our list of the best waterproof eyebrow pencils for swimming! Though the brand itself doesn’t advertise it as a waterproof eyebrow pencil, many avid users would agree to disagree and get behind the fact that this withstands and stays put even as you go swimming. As many users would agree, this stays on and intact as you wear it when you go to the beach or pool, given that you don’t constantly rub your eyebrows.
The brand’s first teardrop tip, this is effective is outlining, filling in, and defining your eyebrows. This is smudge proof and wouldn’t require you to constantly retouch throughout the day as you would experience with other eyebrow pencils in the market. This allows you to achieve natural-looking yet precise brows. This goes on smoothly thanks to its creamy consistency and a saturated, long-lasting tint.
Though not advertised as waterproof, this Maybelline New York eyebrow pencil is sure to withstand active lifestyles – so whether you like running, camping, doing cardio, or even swimming – your brows are sure to stay on fleek. This also doesn’t smudge or rub off on hot weather or when you constantly sweat. No matter what you have planned or what activities you have for the day, this is sure to stay put and intact without ever failing you.
Designed with a built-in spoolie, you can easily and conveniently blend your eyebrows for natural-looking results. There is also a lot of product in the pencil so this is sure to last you a while as you get your money’s worth. Keep in mind though that the waxy tip can wear off easily if you apply it with a heavy hand, so be sure to be gentle during application to preserve the pen further. This is currently offered in 4 shades for all skin tones and hair colors.
Pros:
- Withstands swimming and water activities
- Stays put through an active lifestyle
- No smudging on a hot weather and sweating
- Teardrop tip for outlining, filling in, and defining brows
- Smudge proof and doesn’t rub off
- No constant retouching
- Creamy consistency goes on smoothly and easily
- Stays on even through active lifestyles
- Built-in spoolie for final look blending
- Available in 4 shades
Cons:
- Tip can wear off easily when applied with heavy hands
5. Flower Beauty Draw The Line Eyebrow Pencil
The Flower Beauty Draw The Line Eyebrow Pencil is our last favorite waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming and the last item to have been included in our list! This eyebrow pencil promises a long-lasting and smudge-resistant result as you sport it for an all-day wear. Even as you go swimming and engage in several water activities, this won’t budge and will stay on good without smudging and fading at all. Though the brand doesn’t claim to be waterproof, its longevity and long-lasting formula would beg to disagree.
With this Flower Beauty brow pencil in your makeup routine, you are assured to get smudge proof and water proof results that stays on all day even as you sweat or when your face gets oily as you move around. This is fairly versatile and allows you to achieve either full coverage and bold or light shading and subtle results. The consistency of the pencil also goes on nicely and has a good buildable formula no matter how much you layer in.
Infused with Vitamin E, this conditions as it keeps your brows looking on fleek with a natural-looking and untraceable finish. The pen comes with a built-in spoolie brush on the other end to help you groom and comb through your eyebrows as you blend for a natural look that will last you all day. The brand is also proudly cruelty-free at any stage of their products’ production. If that is something important to you, you might want to check this one out.
A few downsides users have shared about this brow pencil is how the tip can be thin and soft – it can crumble easily if you press on your brows too hard. To make sure you get the most of your money and that you maximize your use of the pencil, do make sure you use gentle hands and handle the brow pencil carefully. The line currently has 3 shades available for you to choose from for all your makeup needs.
Pros:
- Long-lasting and smudge-resistant formula
- Stays on good as you go swimming
- Great for those who get sweaty and greasy
- Full coverage and bold or light shading and subtle looks
- Good consistency with a buildable formula
- Formulated with Vitamin E
- Natural and untraceable finish
- Built-in spoolie for grooming and blending
- Cruelty-free
- Available in 3 shades
Cons:
- Tip is soft and can crumble when pressed too hard
How to Pencil in Eyebrows
To make sure you get your desired results and longevity from your new eyebrow pencil, we list down below some tips and tricks when you pencil in your eyebrows:
Brush your brows
Before you start applying your favorite eyebrow pencil, make sure to brush through your eyebrows first with an eyebrow brush or spoolie. This will help you see your eyebrows’ natural shape and where it archs to guide you in your application.
Use the right shade
To make sure that you get a natural look every single time, it’s very important that you get the right shade of eyebrow pencil. Make sure that the shade you get compliments you, your skin tone, and your hair so that it looks natural and it complements your features.
Short, light strokes
In applying an eyebrow pencil, it’s very important to keep strokes light and regular in order to mimic brow hairs. Make sure you use a light and gente hand in applying and avoid applying too much. You don’t want to end up with a single block-looking pair of eyebrows, so make sure you apply short and light strokes that actually mimic the look of hair brows.
Buff out harsh lines
After you’re satisfied with the shape of your brows, buff out any harsh lines you’ve created using a spoolie by brushing along your brows. This will eliminate any fake-looking appearance on your brows and you will instead achieve a natural, untraceable look.
Practice, practice, practice
If you want to achieve the perfect brows every time, make sure to practice and practice and you are definitely not far from achieving brows that are always on fleek. You know what they say, practice makes perfect, and the same goes for your eyebrows. When you get the hang of applying and defining your brows, you’ll be doing it like it’s second nature to you.
How to Choose the Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil for Swimming
With so many options for eyebrow pencils out in the market right now, it’s important that you know important factors to consider to ensure that you get the best from your many options.
Available shades
An important thing you’d want to keep in mind in looking for your new eyebrow pencil are the shades available. Make sure that what you’re looking at has a variety of shades available and offers a shade that is actually right for you. When it comes to eyebrows and row pencils, it’s very important that you choose and use a shade that complements you and something that will give you confidence.
Built-in spoolie
If you want the complete factor in your new eyebrow pencil, consider getting one that comes with a built-in spoolie. This is very convenient and easy for you to achieve the perfect brows. With a built-in spoolie on your eyebrow pencil, you wouldn’t need to worry about additional tools as you get two things in just one purchase.
Long-lasting formula
As you are looking for an eyebrow pencil you can use for swimming and will actually withstand it, the product’s long-lasting formula is a top priority to consider. Keep an eye out for the worlds ‘waterproof’ or ‘long-lasting’ as this will ensure you that it will stay put on your brows without smudging and fading.
Conclusion
If you enjoy swimming and leisure water activities with friends and family every now and then but don’t want to sacrifice on fleek eyebrows, you should consider getting an eyebrow pencil that stays put even under water.
Our number one pick for the best waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming is the L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer thanks to its waterproof and long-lasting formula that’s perfect for an all-day wear without smudging or fading that stays put even while swimming and under water. The ultra-fine tip also effectively creates strokes that look like your natural brow hairs for a natural finish! If you have sparse brows and are looking for an eyebrow pencil that can effectively fill in gaps and sparse areas, you might want to check out the NYX Micro Brow Pencil! This one also stays put and intact on your brows as you enjoy swimming and the water. And the Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil is our pick for the best splurge option for anyone looking for the best brow pencil for swimming. Its 12-hour waterproof formula promises to stay on your face without budging as you swim and enjoy the waters!
If you still haven’t found your new eyebrow pencil for swimming, we hope our list and guide above have been of great help. Happy shopping and happy swimming!
