Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions

Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions featured photo

If you’re hunting down the best eyelash extensions-safe eyeliner currently available in the market right now, be sure to first stop and consider a few important factors before going ahead with your chosen liner: eyeliner formula, type of eyeliner, and hypoallergenic or dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested factor. I’ve done the tedious research for the best ones in the business so you won’t have to and have them listed and reviewed just below. If you’re ready to find out what made the cut and how these factors I mentioned came into play, be sure to read along!

One of my favorite facial features are my eyelashes. Luckily, I was gifted with naturally long and thick lashes. It’s also one of the few things people immediately notice about me and I would be lying if I say I don’t enjoy the few compliments here and there. In return, it’s one of the few things I first notice about other people too. Some are gifted with naturally lengthy and voluminous lashes while some are on the thinner side of lashes – and that’s totally okay and beautiful just the same!

Even if I do believe that all lashes are beautiful and no one should ever be made to feel like they should be conforming to society’s judgements, I do understand and get why many choose to go for artificial lashes like fake lashes and extensions for that length and volume. I’ve seen a couple friends sporting eyelash extensions and I think they’re so beautiful and just so fluffy! Many would think you can’t wear any eye makeup on your lashes with extensions on but that’s just the opposite.

When it comes to eyelash extensions and putting makeup on or near them, you have to keep an eye on certain formulas that are sure to be safe for them. For eyeliners on eyelash extensions, you don’t need to look further as I have the best and my favorites all listed below!

Can I Wear Eyeliner with Eyelash Extensions?

Eyelash extensions are made to make you feel made up every morning you wake up for that boost of confidence and to make you feel better about yourself. Many people believe that when you get eyelash extensions, you should also have to say goodbye to all the eye makeup products you used to enjoy before getting the extensions done. You have to be extra careful on applying carefully selected products, yes, but you don’t have to completely stop using them for the sake of your extensions.

For anyone who wants that extra glamor and those who are used to playing around and having fun with their eye makeup, your eyelash extensions shouldn’t ever get in your way of achieving that with an eyeliner. You can still wear eyeliner with your lash extensions, of course, you just have to keep in mind some dos and don’ts when it comes to choosing the right product.

To keep it short, the perfect eyeliner for eyelash extensions should be washable instead of waterproof, water-based instead of oil-based, and should glide on lids easily and not cause tugging or pulling on your lids. We’ll discuss more of this and what you should consider later on in the article, so stay tuned if you want to learn more.

Safely removing eyeliner with eyelash extensions

When you’re wearing lash extensions and eyeliner, one thing you should focus on to ensure that you don’t ruin your extensions is safely removing them at the end of the day. So, how do you carefully remove eyeliner without running your extensions?

  • No oil-based makeup remover
  • Be gentle and don’t use too much pressure in removing eyeliner
  • Use a cotton bud to gently remove the eyeliner
  • Opt for micellar water instead of harsh makeup removers
  • Only use a cotton bud to remove any residue

Now that we’ve got all that covered out of the way, let’s now move on to our list of current favorites!

Our Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Eyelash Extensions

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our PickBeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid EyelinerBeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid EyelinerCheck Price
Best for Natural Lash HealthLavish Liner by Hairgenics EyelinerLavish Liner by HairgenicsCheck Price
Best for Line VersatilityXtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid EyelinerXtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid EyelinerCheck Price
Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye PencilXtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye PencilCheck Price
Maybelline New York Master Precise All Day Liquid EyelinerMaybelline New York Master Precise All Day Liquid EyelinerCheck Price

The Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions

1. BeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid Eyeliner – Our Pick!

BeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid Eyeliner

Our number one pick for the best eyeliners for eyelash extensions is the BeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid Eyeliner! An oil-free eyeliner and water-based formula, this promises to be extremely safe for lash extensions while allowing you to achieve the perfect line you are going for to complete your eye makeup look. With this in your makeup routine, you are not only able to achieve any liner look you want but also preserve the life of your extensions and be able to wear them longer while keeping them intact.

This BeautyGarde eyeliner promises to protect your lash adhesive, whether you’re wearing extensions or false eyelashes. This will definitely come in handy for those who wear lash extensions as it actively helps prolong their life and time on your lashes. This one is very easy to remove just with just soap and water so you can rest assured you will not ruin your extensions in an effort of removing makeup. Don’t be fooled though by how easy it is to remove because this is also very smudge proof and long-lasting without any signs of fading or smearing.

Designed with a unique and flocked-tip applicator, this eyeliner allows you to achieve professional precision and lines that are so easy to achieve whether you’re going for subtle and thin or bold and dramatic. The precision tip also makes this eyeliner very easy to apply even for absolute beginners. A quick reminder though that not everyone has been the biggest fan of the applicator brush as some found it to be too thin and might need a little bit more work if you’re going for thicker and bolder lines.

The oil-free formula of this BeautyGarde eyeliner is guaranteed to work and be safe on eyelash extensions so you won’t have to worry about it at all. This is super delicate on extensions and wouldn’t get stuck on them, causing possible fallout and ruining them altogether. With this eyeliner in your makeup routine, you don’t just get that blob of mascara on your eyelids as you would with other eyeliners but instead you will get precise lines that are sure to accentuate your eyes even more.

This eyeliner is proud to be Leaping Bunny certified and is a hundred percent cruelty-free without testing on any animals at any point. This is also free from any toxic ingredients and if hypoallergenic, making it very safe to use on those with sensitive skin and eyes. There is also no fragrance, paraben, glycol, or gluten in its formula. If these are important things for you in your makeup, be sure to check this one out.

Pros:

  • Water-based and oil-free formula eyeliner
  • Safe for lash extensions and prolongs their life
  • Actively protects the adhesive of lash extensions
  • Smudge proof and stays on lids without fading
  • Easy to remove with just water
  • Doesn’t get stuck on lash extensions
  • Precision tip applies liner easily for whatever look
  • Helps accentuate eyes and lashes
  • Leaping Bunny certified and cruelty-free
  • Hypoallergenic, no toxic ingredients and no fragrance

Cons:

  • Applicator may be too thin for some users

2. Lavish Liner by Hairgenics – Best for Natural Lash Health!

Lavish Liner by Hairgenics Eyeliner

Our next favorite eyeliner for eyelash extensions and our best choice for natural lash health is the Lavish Liner by Hairgenics! If what you’re looking for is an eyeliner that is not only lash extension-friendly but one that will also boost your natural lashes’ health, then you might be in for a treat with this one. A 2-in-1 formula, this promises to enhance and boost your eyelash growth as it allows you to achieve the line you’re going for to complete your eye makeup look – whether you’re going for thin and subtle or thick and bold.

With this Lavish Liner part of your makeup routine, you are sure to achieve your desired eye makeup without having to worry whether or not it can ruin your lash extensions as this is very safe and friendly on them. Though boasting of a water-resistant and smudge proof formula that is sure to stay on your lids all day or night, this washes off easily at the end of the day and wouldn’t cause any harm on your lashes or the adhesive. With this liner, you can rest assured that your extensions could have much prolonged life on your lashes.

The nourishing and lash boosting formula of this eyeliner has been infused with the brand’s cult-favorite botanical eyelash serum with biotin and castor oil to naturally improve the length and volume of your natural lashes. Ther serum-infused formula will allow you to naturally achieve longer, fuller, and thicker lashes in as few as 60 days. Many users would agree that the boosting serum eyeliner really does help lengthen and volumize eyelashes as it gives you the freedom to achieve any eye makeup look you want.

Designed with an ultra-precise applicator brush, you are sure to achieve thin or thick lines for your eyelids with much ease and comfort. The tip also promises to dispense only the right amount of liner product so you don’t ever end up with messy lids that could ruin your entire makeup. The formula of this liner also glides on and applies easily with much precision and allows you to create thin, delicate lines with much ease. This is able to apply lines on your lids without pressure and tugging – something you really need with eyelash extensions.

Made only with the highest quality of ingredients, you are sure to get only the best with this one, even with its pricier price compared to others in the market. This has also been clinically-tested, allergy-tested, and dermatologist-tested – firmly assuring that the formula is non-irritating and hypoallergenic. This is a great option for those with sensitive eyes and skin as well.

Pros:

  • Ideal for natural lash health
  • Safe for lash extensions
  • Boosts natural lashes’ length and volume
  • 2-in1- formula that nourishes as it lines the eyelids
  • Water-resistant and smudge proof for an all day wear
  • Washes off easily with just soap and water
  • Allows you to achieve thinker, longer, and fuller in just 60 days
  • Ultra-precise brush for easy application of thin or thick lines
  • No pressure or tugging during application
  • Dermatologist, allergy, and clinically-tested
  • Non-irritating and hypoallergenic

Cons:

  • A bit pricey

3. Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid Eyeliner – Best for Liner Versatility!

Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid Eyeliner

The next item on our list of the best eyeliners for eyelash extensions and our pick for the best liner versatility is the Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid Eyeliner! If you’re on the hunt for an eyeliner that can offer you maximum line versatility, you might want to check this one out. Designed with a double-sided felt tip, you are sure to get the most out of this liner, whether you’re going for subtle thin lines with the Precision Tip on one end or dramatic thick lines with the Style Edge Tip on the other end.

With this eyeliner in your makeup kit, you don’t have to worry about ruining your lash extensions anymore as this is formulated to be compatible with them. This is sure to not cause any fallout or issues with your lash extensions at all. This has been formulated to be removed easily at the end of the day and will not get stuck on your lash extensions. Don’t be alarmed though by the fact that this can be easily removed as this still boasts of a formula that doesn’t smudge or budge and a long-wearing power that stays on all day.

A formula enriched with peptide, this is sure to nourish and boost your natural lashes as well on top of allowing you to achieve your desired lines no matter how thin or how thick. The formula is also very easy to apply and easily glides and smoothly on your lids without much trouble. This has been formulated specifically for use on extensions but works just as well on natural lashes if ever you choose to do so, and what more, it helps nourish and keeps them at optimum health. This also applies without flaking on your extensions or natural lashes.

The convenient dual-ended eyeliner is sure to make your eyeliner sessions easier and much more comfortable. The two unique tips come in very handy whether you’re going for thin and subtle or thick and bold. Each tip would allow you to easily achieve your desired results with intense precision, ease, and control. You can trust this eyeliner to provide foolproof and perfect results every single time thanks to its unique two tips.

Having been dermatologist-tested and formulated to be hypoallergenic, this is sure to be safe for use on those with sensitive skin and eyes without causing any irritation of some sort. There are currently two available shades to choose from for your needs: black and dark brown. Though on the pricier side of eyeliners, many users would agree that this is worth what you pay for as it is very safe for lash extensions. One downside users have shared about this liner is that it may actually require reapplication throughout the day as it could start fading.

Pros:

  • Ideal for liner versatility
  • Double-sided felt tip for precise and easy application
  • Each tip allows for maximum application control
  • No smudging or budging and great long-staying power
  • Washes off easily when you say it’s time to go
  • Peptide-enriched formula to nourish natural lashes
  • Glides on easily and smoothly
  • No flaking or build-up on lashes
  • Foolproof results every single time
  • Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested

Cons:

  • A bit pricey
  • Might start to fade at the end of the day

4. Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

Our next favorite eyeliner for eyelash extensions is another one from Xtreme Lashes and it is the GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil! Also formulated for use with eyelash extensions, this is sure to give you your desired eye makeup look while keeping your lashes safe and intact. Combining the benefits of a liquid liner formula with the easy application of a traditional pencil liner, this is sure to be lash extensions-friendly and actively help you prolong the life of your extensions.

A convenient glider pencil, this eyeliner promises smooth and easy application without tugging as you would have experienced with traditional pencils. The easy glide-on formula applies like butter, something lash extensions are in search of whether you’re going for thin lines or thick lines. The formula blends upon application and dries to a smudge proof finish that stays on all day or all night without any signs of running or fading. And no worries for your extensions as this is easy to remove without compromising your extensions or its adhesive.

The silky-smooth and Vitamin E-infused gel formula of this pencil liner allows you to achieve intensely pigmented results that apply with great precision for perfectly defined eyes that can only emphasize. The pencil is very soft and gentle on extensions unlike other pencils in the market, allowing gentle and lash extensions-friendly application as well. This is currently available in a variety of 13 shades and you are sure to find one that’s perfect for your daily makeup needs.

Because the gel pencil is soft, many users notice that it seems like the pencil needs to be sharpened quite often as it can easily wear down with every application. Because of this, a pencil would not seem to last very long, of course, you need to take into account how often you plan to use this as part of your makeup routine.

Pros:

  • Formulated for use on eyelash extensions
  • Benefits of liquid with the easy application of pencil eyeliner
  • Vitamin E-enriched formula
  • Glides on easily without tugging
  • Applies like butter and easily blends upon application
  • Smudge proof and long-wearing without running or fading
  • Easy to remove and safe for extensions
  • Pigmented results and precise application
  • Available in a variety of 13 shades

Cons:

  • So soft it would need to sharpened frequently

5. Maybelline New York Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner

Maybelline New York Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner

The Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner from beauty brand Maybelline New York is the last item that made it into our list of the best eyeliners for eyelash extensions! The smudge proof formula of this eyeliner allows you to wear it with confidence for up to a whopping 12 hours without any signs or running or fading while still being friendly and safe for use on those who wear eyelash extensions. The formula is very easy to remove at the end of the day, throwing away all possibilities of ruining your extensions or the adhesive.

The formula of this Maybelline New York eyeliner glides on smoothly and easily, whether you’re going for a thin line or for a dramatic eye look. It also doesn’t form any ugly glop of black line but instead lets you draw precise and smooth lines every single time. The ultra-fine tip this liner comes with allows you to achieve defined and precise lines that are sure to stay put to define your eyes. This is currently available in 3 shades – black, forest brown, and matte balck, for all your makeup needs no matter the occasion.

Dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested and free from fragrance, you can trust this one to be safe for use on sensitive eyes and skin and for those who wear contact lenses. This promises you no irritation on your eyes and on skin at all. The only con users have seemed to notice about the product is how it can dry up fast after a few weeks of use. If you choose to go with this one for your lash extensions, do keep that factor in mind.

Pros:

  • Smudge proof for 12 hours without fading or running
  • Easy to remove from lash line – safe for lash extensions
  • Glides on smoothly and easily
  • Allows for precise and defined lines
  • Ultra-fine tip for easy application
  • Available in 3 shades
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons:

  • Pen and product can dry up fast

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions

With so many eyeliner options available for you and me both, it can be confusing to choose which one will really be the best for your lash extensions and makeup needs. It’s important for you to keep in mind the factors below to make sure you get your hands on the best of the best.

Eyeliner formula

The first thing to look at when looking for an eyeliner for your lash extensions is the formula. Remember, not all eyeliner formulas are safe for extensions.

Oil-free and water-based: Oil-based eyeliners are something you should stay away from when you have lash extensions. Oil can damage the glue and adhesive of your ash extensions, shortening their life. You should also go oil-free on any eye makeup when you have lash extensions on. For eyeliners, it’s better that you opt for water-based ones.

Washable and not waterproof: When choosing an eyeliner that’s safe for eyelash extensions, keep in mind that the formula has to be washable and not waterproof. Waterproof eyeliners are amazing when it comes to staying power and staying fresh-looking no matter how many hours you wear it. For eyelash extensions, however, they’re totally a no-go. Waterproof eyeliners would require you to use strong makeup removers that can potentially ruin your lash extensions. For lash extensions, go for a washable eyeliner instead that still has great staying power and is smudge proof.

Formula that glides: Last thing to keep in mind formula-wise is to get an eyeliner that glides on lids easily without tugging so it couldn’t potentially ruin your extensions and the adhesive. Eyeliners that tug on your lids and lash line can only ruin your extensions and can cause fallout.

Type of eyeliner

When looking for an eyeliner to use for eyelash extensions, the type is actually an important factor to consider. For the safety of your lash extensions, it’s better that you choose liquid liners as these are sure to have formulas that glide on easily without tugging and without the need to apply so much pressure. You might also want to stay away from most pencil and gel liners and the formula of these types require more effort and pressure on your lids, something that can harm your lash extensions.

Hypoallergenic, dermatologist or ophthalmologist-tested

If you’re someone with sensitive eyes and skin or just someone who would like to avoid any irritations at all, you might want to keep an eye out for formulas that are hypoallergenic or have been dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested for assurance of safety of use.

Conclusion

Eyeliners are a good way to go whenever you want that extra glamour in your makeup look. While it is true that not all eyeliners are safe for eyelash extensions, you can definitely find some that are safe to use with extensions on.

Our number one pick for the best eyeliner for eyelash extensions is the BeautyGarde Oil-Free Liquid Eyeliner thanks to its water-based and oil-free formula that also actively protects your extensions and its adhesive. The formula is also smudge proof and promises to stay on all day while still being easy to remove at the end of the day! If what you’re looking for is an eyeliner that will not only give you the perfect lines to complete your eye makeup look but also one that will help boost the length and volume of your lashes, you might want to check out the Lavish Liner by Hairgenics! Its formula has been infused with lash-boosting serum that helps nourish and keep them long, voluminous, and overall healthy. And the Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid Eyeliner is our number one pick for the best liner versatility! The double-sided tip allows you to easily either thin and subtle lines or thick and bold lines.

We hope you were able to find your new go-to eyeliner that can go with your eyelash extensions!

Related Articles