Best Shaving Soap for Sensitive Skin

man shaving in front of mirror

If you’re looking for the best sensitive skin-friendly shaving soap to elevate your shaving experience, you should probably stop to consider a few important things: the ingredients, scent, its lifespan, and the price range it’s in. With these things in mind, I reviewed below the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin. So go ahead and give this one a read if you’re interested.

Shaving is part of every man’s routine. Whether you shave once every single day or just once every few days, shaving shouldn’t be a chore you dread! Shaving should be an experience you look forward to every morning you wake up.

I’ve had my fair share of experience with shaving, with shaving my legs every few weeks. And with that, I’ve also had my fair share of razor cuts and burns. With consistent cuts and burns everytime I shave, I started researching ways and remedies to avoid these. And this is how I stumbled upon shaving soaps and how amazing they work for effortless and a more comfortable shaving.

If you have sensitive skin, you might be one of those people who dread when you have to shave because you get horrible cuts and razor burns every. single. time. If your usual shaving cream isn’t protecting your skin every time you shave anymore, then switching to a shaving soap might just do the trick for you.

With the right shaving soap in your shaving routine, it could give your skin enough protection and prevent the usual cuts and burns. If you’re lucky enough you can even find one that’s sure to moisturize and soothe sensitive and irritated skin.

How Do I Know if I Have Sensitive Skin?

If you’re experimenting on new facial products and you often get unusual skin reactions, that is a definite sign that you have sensitive skin. Your skin can react through irritation and redness. Constant skin itching and dryness can also be indicators of skin sensitivity.

If you’re trying on a facial or skin product, you might feel stinging or burning when its ingredients aren’t compatible with your sensitive skin. People with sensitive skin are also often prone to developing acne.

Having sensitive skin will often force you to be wary of the products you put on your face and the rest of your skin. You would want to opt for gentle and mild products, and sometimes even avoid ones with scent as these are known irritants to sensitive skin.

If you’re thinking of getting a new shaving soap for your sensitive skin, read on because we list down and review below the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin!

Our Top Picks for the Best Shaving Soap for Sensitive Skin

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our PickProraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive SkinProraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive SkinCheck Price
Best MoisturizingHenry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving SoapHenry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving SoapCheck Price
Best Travel-FriendlySir Hare Shaving SoapSir Hare Shaving SoapCheck Price
Men’s Soap Company Himalaya Shaving SoapMen’s Soap Company Himalaya Shaving SoapCheck Price
Col. Conk Bay Rum Shaving SoapCol. Conk Bay Rum Shaving SoapCheck Price

The Best Shaving Soaps for Sensitive Skin

1. Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin – Our Pick!

Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin

Our pick for the best shaving soap for sensitive skin is the Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin! This shaving soap gives you a dense, soft, and luxurious lather with a fresh, clean scent that has some staying power to it and you will surely look for it every time you shave. It has a great finish and leaves your skin feeling moisturized post-shave.

It has good anti-inflammatory properties too, with its oatmeal and green tea components help calm, soothe, and protect sensitive and irritated skin. The nice and slick lather helps your razor, no matter what kind you’re using, glide easily and effortlessly over your skin. The thick cream of this shaving soap is able to load up very easily into your brush and allows you to get a very close shave. And don’t worry, this doesn’t quickly dry out when on your face, unlike other shaving products.

It doesn’t cause redness or irritation on your skin thanks to its very effective anti-inflammatory properties. A good pre-shave and preparation will definitely help the shaving soap perform better. A tub of this is sure to last you for months as a little amount of the product goes a long way so you’re certain to get your money’s worth.

Pros:

  • Great inflammatory properties
  • Soothes and calms sensitive skin
  • No redness or irritation
  • Luxurious lather
  • Gives skin a moisturized finish
  • Will last you for months
  • No parabens and silicones

Cons:

  • Hint of menthol is not for everyone

2. Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap – Best Moisturizing!

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap

If your constant problem is your skin feeling very dry after every shave, then the Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap might be what you’re looking for! The second item on our list as the best moisturizing shaving soap for sensitive skin, this one has shea butter as one of its main ingredients that leaves your skin feeling smooth and nicely moisturized, without the tacky oiliness. It also has soy extracts to comfort and condition for a much softer skin.

This shaving soap lathers up quickly and richly too, helping protect your skin better from cuts and razor burns and even allows you to close shave. The much thicker texture allows your razor to glide much smoothly and easily on your skin. It also holds up well on your skin, without drying up while you’re in the process of shaving.

Post-shave, it leaves your skin feeling clean but not dry at all, and instead deeply moisturized. It also rinses off easily with water, not leaving you with sticky residue on your skin. It has a nice mild fragrance to it but not overpowering at all, like with other shaving soaps and creams. Using this every time you shave actually soothes your skin and leaves it feeling much softer.

Pros:

  • Moisturizes skin after shaving
  • Soothes sensitive skin
  • Reduces razor bumps and irritation
  • Rich and creamy lather
  • Skin feels clean and moisturized
  • Rinses off easily without residue
  • Mild fragrance

Cons:

  • None

3. Sir Hare Shaving Soap – Best Travel-Friendly!

Sir Hare Shaving Soap

Our pick for the best travel-friendly shaving soap for sensitive skin is the Sir Hare Shaving Soap! If you’re one to constantly travel whether for leisure, work, or attending special events, and find that carrying your shaving soap plus an extra bowl a hassle when you pack things to bring with you, you might want to check this one out.

This shaving soap is packed in a container that has extra space in it, which means no more extra bowls to lather up your shaving soap! It also has a screw-in lid that keeps the product safe from spilling during travel.

This one also has a nice lather to it that feels luxurious on the skin. It lathers up quickly and easily and allows you to achieve close shaves without the constant irritation due to razor burns. It’s also able to leave your skin feeling smoother and moisturized after every shave. It has a clean and aromatic scent that’s noticeable in a good way. If you don’t prefer any scent at all, don’t worry because the scent in this doesn’t linger much on your face.

Pros:

  • Extra bowl space and screw-in lid for travel
  • Nice, luxurious lather
  • No irritation and razor burns
  • Skin is soft and moisturized
  • Clean and aromatic scent

Cons:

  • None

4. Men’s Soap Company Himalaya Shaving Soap

Men’s Soap Company Himalaya Shaving Soap

The next item on our list of the best shaving soap for sensitive skin is the Himalaya Shaving Soap from Men’s Soap Company! This shaving soap has a thick and rich lather that you can easily whip to achieve. The extra creamy lather this shaving soap gives you helps your razor glide smoothly on your skin and won’t leave you with cruel razor burns.

This also doesn’t irritate sensitive skin, so if your skin falls under that category, you don’t have to worry. Your skin even feels fresh and clean after shaving. A bar of this is sure to last you for months so you really get your money’s worth. It has a subtle himalaya scent that will make you come back for more.

The company also has amazing customer service, as proven by loyal consumers. They send you numerous follow-up emails to assist you in using their shaving soap and to make sure you’re satisfied with their product.

Pros:

  • Thick and rich lather
  • No razor burns
  • Doesn’t irritate sensitive skin
  • Subtle Himalaya scent
  • Great customer service
  • Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons:

  • Scent is not for everyone

5. Col. Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Col. Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Col. Conk’s Bay Rum Shaving Soap also made it into our list of the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin! This shaving soap lathers up well and easily too. The lather holds up well on your skin without drying too fast, therefore your razor glides smoothly and you avoid the usual razor burns. Thanks to its glycerin content, it doesn’t leave your skin feeling dry after every shave, it instead leaves you feeling refreshed.

It also leaves you with a smooth and well-moisturized skin without the uncomfortable greasy feeling. It rinses off easily with water leaving no greasy residue. It also has a nice but far from overwhelming scent. A single puck of this can last you for months and with a single purchase, you get three pucks. Talk about getting your money’s worth!

Pros:

  • Great lather, doesn’t dry too quickly
  • Razor glides smoothly and no razor burns
  • Doesn’t dry out skin
  • Leaves skin smooth and moisturized
  • Non-greasy
  • Comes in three pucks

Cons:

  • Decent lather, not too thick

Shaving Soap vs Shaving Cream

We’ve talked about shaving soaps for the entirety of this article and we have yet to discuss a very important question: shaving soap and shaving cream, what’s the difference?

Lather building

The main difference between a shaving cream and a shaving soap is how you build up your lather. Shaving creams generally contain more water, which means they are softer in consistency and don’t require much effort to build up the lather. Shaving creams are usually the go-to for beginner shavers.

Shaving soaps come in pucks in either bowls or jars. They’re initially hard and would require you to put in more effort to build up your lather. You will need a bowl, a shaving brush, and water to do so. It takes time, patience, and a bit more experienced technique to really reach a creamy and thick lather for your skin’s protection.

Scent

When it comes to scent and fragrance, shaving soaps take the cake as manufacturers make it a point to give their shaving soaps unique sets of scents and fragrance. Most often, these scents will remind users of a traditional barber shop that will really make you feel fresh and really well taken care of.

Longevity

Shaving soaps often last longer than shaving creams. With shaving soaps, you get a hardened puck of soap that you can build up and lather. A single purchase of it is sure to last you for months. Shaving creams don’t allow room for much longevity.

Ingredients

Shaving soaps are generally made of mostly natural ingredients as compared to shaving creams. This makes them a better choice for those with extra sensitive skin as you avoid putting a lot of chemicals on your face everytime you shave.

Why Should You Use a Shaving Soap?

Shaving soaps have been around since the 1800s but very few today regularly turn to them when it’s time to shave, which is honestly a shame with all the benefits and advantages you can get when you use shaving soaps.

Close shave

One of the things shaving soap users love is how they’re able to get a much closer shave than with most shaving products. Because shaving soaps are able to really penetrate into the whiskers, this allows them to soften them up for an easier and closer shave.

Hydration

Shaving soaps, as compared to other shaving products, provide your skin with intense hydration. After shaving, your skin wouldn’t feel too dry as moisture isn’t stripped off of your face and instead retained on the inside.

Thick, creamy lather

Shaving soaps require a bit more effort to really build up the lather as compared to other shaving products in the market. But once you are able to build that up, you are provided with a thick and luxurious lather to protect your skin from irritation and razor burns.

Natural ingredients

Shaving soaps are known to be made of mostly natural ingredients. This is especially a benefit for those with sensitive skin. If your usual shaving product isn’t as mild and gentle as you’d want it to be on your skin, you might want to take a look and try out shaving soaps.

Cheaper

Unlike other shaving products, a single puck of shaving soap is sure to last you for months. This means you purchase and spend less for your shaving needs. And depending on the brand, refill pucks are also readily available for you to purchase at a cheaper price compared to buying one in a bowl or container.

How to Choose the Best Shaving Soap for Sensitive Skin

If you’re thinking of switching to a shaving soap for your sensitive skin, you are one step closer to achieving better shaves. But with so many shaving soaps out in the market now, it can be overwhelming and confusing to decide which will work best for your skin. Here, we list down things you should consider when looking for the shaving soap that will do you wonders.

Ingredients

Always, always read through the product’s ingredient list and make sure only quality ingredients are in it. Also make sure that you aren’t sensitive or allergic to any of the ingredients listed. We don’t want any more problems in trying to find the perfect shaving soap for your skin.

For sensitive skin, it’s better to opt for something mostly made out of natural ingredients. This will lessen your chances of developing irritation, redness, and other allergic reactions.

Scent

Scent and fragrance in your shaving soap is mostly a personal preference. Choose something you know you’d be comfortable with as you are most likely putting it near your nose. If you’re extra sensitive to scent and are prone to have reactions to it, go for something that doesn’t have any scent or fragrance at all to be on the safer side.

Lifespan

While shaving soaps generally will last you for quite a few months, some last longer than others. Some are bigger in size than others, too. Check reviews and see what other users say about how long it can last you. Go for something that can last for a good few months and at the same time will help you achieve a quality shave.

Price

It’s always important to consider the product’s price no matter what you’re considering buying. High-end shaving soaps can be more costly but are sure to have quality ingredients. Some that come in cheaper prices can still have quality ingredients that work wonders on your skin. Consider how much you’re willing to pay for shaving soaps and go for something that’s in the price range you’re comfortable spending.

Conclusion

Switching to a shaving soap can be a very big leap for anyone. There are so many choices out in the market today for those with skin sensitivities. It can get overwhelming with so many results in just a single Google search but it doesn’t necessarily have to be.

The Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin is our number one for the best shaving soap for sensitive skin for its dense, soft, and luxurious lather and anti-inflammatory properties to calm and soothe sensitive and irritated skin whenever you have your razor in hand. The Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap is our choice for the best moisturizing shaving soap for sensitive skin for its moisturizing and hydrating properties that won’t leave your skin feeling dry after every shave. And if you’re one to constantly travel to different places from time to time, the Sir Hare Shaving Soap might be a very good choice thanks to its screw-in lid and extra bowl space that wouldn’t require you to bring an extra for when you’re traveling.

We hope that by reading through this article, you have found the best shaving soap your sensitive skin needs and looks for every time you shave.