Best Organic Eye Creams

Best Organic Eye Creams featured photo

If you’re currently looking for the best organic eye creams out in the market right now, be sure you are able to check on a few items that should be on your checklist: your eye concerns, the ingredients, and the price point. I took it upon myself to look for and research some of the best in the business right now. With these mentioned factors in mind, I list and review all my favorites below for you and I both. I hope you’re ready to dive into my current favorites as we scroll along right now!

One of my constant skin issues is the state of my under eyes. I’ve always had dark circles under my eyes and I would be lying if I say it has not been a constant source of insecurity over the years. Normally, I would not think about it too much so as not to make myself feel bad. But lately, I’ve been wanting to change up a few things and steps in my skincare routine just to see and experiment on other products. One of the few things that keep popping up during my research are eye creams. Surprisingly, I haven’t tried that many eye creams before, and I think it’s time for me to find the one to answer my eye issues.

Ever since I started building up my skincare routine, I made it a point to only include and use clean, organic, and natural products that have been sustainably sourced. It’s not about simply being picky. I have sensitive skin that doesn’t react well to a lot of products that contain mostly chemical ingredients. My skin would also react by itching or burning when I use the wrong product, and so I have always been careful in choosing skincare products and I think I should now apply the same carefulness when it comes to eye creams.

I hope you’re ready to dive in on my current favorites right now!

What is Organic Skincare?

When we say ‘organic’, it means that the ingredients used in making the product have entirely been naturally and organically grown and derived – aka without chemicals, pesticides, fertilizers, parabens, or any other toxic chemicals. Not all organic products are a hundred percent organic and should meet a certain percentage of organic ingredients in order to fall under the category of being ‘certified organic’.

Products that fall under the category ‘organic’ also means they follow stricter standards than the general products in the market. This assures you that you are getting products that have undergone a lot of scrutiny and are definitely clean. When it comes to making sure a product is indeed organic, it’s important that consumers like you and me, really look at the ingredients list and not just at the label that says ‘organic’.

Many people, especially in recent years, have made the switch from chemicals to organic when it comes to food. If organic food presents so many good things and advantages to our body when consumed, surely skincare products that are organic should be healthier for our skin too, right?

Why you should go organic

If you’re still on the fence on whether or not you should go organic when we’re talking about skincare, we have listed below some reasons why you should exactly make the switch.

  • There are no harmful preservatives, parabens, and silicones that can potentially harm the skin
  • Absence of a lot of toxins that can possibly cause allergies and unwarranted skin reactions
  • The ingredients used to manufacture the product did not make use of any artificial pesticides that is harmful to both your skin and to the environment
  • There are no unnecessary synthetics and fragrances added in its ingredients
  • Sustainable farming is used in growing ingredients for organic skincare products and it would mean that you are avoiding farming practices that can harm and cause a negative impact on the environment
  • Organic is safer not only for your skin, but also for the environment

So there you go, let’s now dive right into our current favorite organic eye creams!

Our To Picks for the Best Organic Eye Creams

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our Pick100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye CreamCheck Price
Best for HydrationSpirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye CreamSpirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye CreamCheck Price
Best Anti-AgingTata Harper Restorative Eye CrèmeTata Harper Restorative Eye CrèmeCheck Price
Beauty by Earth Coffee Bean Eye CreamBeauty by Earth Coffee Bean Eye CreamCheck Price
Nourish Organic Renewing & Hydrating Eye TreatmentNourish Organic Renewing & Hydrating Eye TreatmentCheck Price

The Best Organic Eye Creams

1. 100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream – Our Pick!

100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream

Our number one pick for the best organic eye cream is the 100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream! Made to refresh and hydrate the delicate area under your eyes, this has been formulated with stimulating and firming ingredients to help increase circulation and reduce puffiness around the area. Every time you include this in your morning and evening skincare routine, you are one step closer in reducing the appearance of dark circles and fine lines and wrinkles around the eyes that could make you look older.

Infused with only nourishing and clean ingredients like rosehip oil, vitamin E that actively fights against free radicals, and vitamin C to help boost your skin’s collagen production, this 100% Pure eye cream is sure to be your armor in fighting against wrinkles, fine lines, and other signs of aging. The hydrating aloe and rose hydrosol included in its pool of clean ingredients also help you achieve and bring back skin that is fresh, dewy, and overall youthful-looking, especially in the delicate around your eyes.

Using this as part of your morning and evening eye care routine will help increase and improve hydration and moisture, actively helping you maintain and bring back a more youthful appearance around your eye area. This is also helpful in brightening and revitalizing dull skin around the eyes. This eye cream boasts of having 3 types of natural caffeine, to give tired and dull-looking eyes and give time extra love and care to revitalize and revive them back to optimum health.

On top of reducing puffiness, dark circles, and the appearance of various signs of aging around the eye area, this caffeine eye cream also assures its users to leave the eyes intensely moisturized throughout the day. This also helps in firming up droopy eye areas that can also show aging. Sensitive eyes are also safe to use and wouldn’t cause any unwanted skin reactions. This also works well under makeup. It’s neither too dewy or too drying and is sure to not cause any makeup pilling, completely ruining your get up.

This is proudly vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and made with ethically-sourced and all-natural ingredients without any harsh or toxic ingredients, chemicals, or dyes. There is also a scent of warm vanilla latte that comes along with this eye cream. Keep in mind though that the initial blast of coffee scent is not to everyone’s preference. Some users have also stated that the tube can be quite small, especially given the price. No worries though as you only need a little amount at a time so this is sure to last you for quite a long time.


  • Stimulates and boosts circulation on the eye area
  • Reduces the appearance of puffiness and dark circles
  • Helps bring back the eye’s youthful look
  • Reduces the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles
  • Boosts skin’s collagen production
  • Increases hydration and moisture around the eyes
  • Eye area looks fresh, dewy, and bright
  • Works well under makeup
  • Vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free
  • Free from harsh and toxic ingredients
  • Made with only ethically-sourced and all-natural ingredients
  • A little goes a long way
  • Warm vanilla scent


  • Scent is not for everyone
  • Tube can be small for the price

2. Spirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye Cream – Best for Hydration!

Spirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye Cream

The next item on our list of the best organic eye creams and our top choice for the best hydration benefits is the Spirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye Cream! If what you’re prioritizing in your new eye cream is intense hydration and moisture, then you might be in for a treat with this one. With this clean eye cream as part of your skincare routine day in and day out, you are sure to moisturize and hydrate your dry eye area and help them lock in moisture for an all-day comfortable feeling.

Formulated with both shea butter and jojoba oil, this Spirit Nest eye cream is sure to revitalize and provide your eye area with deep nourishment and hydration. The clover in its pool of ingredients also actively helps renew and nourish the gentle skin of the eyes. On top of providing intense hydration and moisture, you can also trust this to fight against multiple signs of aging. With consistent use, this is sure to help lessen the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines.

Though this provides intense hydration for dry and thirsty areas of your eyes, this will never leave you feeling oily and greasy. The overall consistency of this eye cream is light yet is able to moisturize well. It also goes well under your makeup so you never end up looking cakey, no matter the occasion. Every drop of this eye cream is sure to help awaken your eye area while actively restoring a much youthful look all the while minimizing the appearance of puffiness and dark circles on tired and sleep-deprived eyes.

The deep hydrating formula of this Spirit Nest eye cream promises to leave your thirsty skin quenched with a fast-absorbing formula. This also helps soften and smooth out fine lines around the eyes so they may appear less visible, especially under layers of makeup. There is also a light scent to it that isn’t overpowering at all, though not every user is a big fan of the scent, so keep that factor in mind. A little goes a long way, though some users noticed that the bottle can pump out a little too much than what is needed, so make sure to be careful in that department.

And because we only want the best for you and your skin, we made sure that this is safe for all skin types. Even those with sensitive skin have experienced no breakouts or reactions. Its use of only clean, natural, and organic ingredients is sure to be safe on skin sensitivities. The formula is also proudly vegan and has been formulated with only pure, safe, and fresh ingredients without parabens or any toxins that can harm you and your skin.


  • Ideal for deep hydration and moisture
  • Locks in moisture so eyes don’t feel dry throughout the day
  • Revitalizes dry eyes and provides deep nourishment
  • Actively helps fight against signs of aging
  • Moisturizing yet non-oily and non-greasy formula
  • Lightweight consistency
  • Goes well under makeup and never appears cakey
  • Soften and smooths out appearance of fine lines
  • Fast-absorbing and quick-sinking formula
  • Light scent isn’t overpowering
  • Safe for all skin types, even sensitive skin
  • Formulated only with clean, natural, and organic ingredients
  • Vegan formula without parabens or toxins


  • Scent is not for everyone
  • Bottle can pump out too much at a time

3. Tata Harper Restorative Eye Crème – Best Anti-Aging!

Tata Harper Restorative Eye Crème

Our next favorite organic eye cream and our pick for the best anti-aging eye cream is the Tata Harper Restorative Eye Crème! If your main concern is reducing the appearance of various signs of aging around your eye area, be sure to check this one out. A multi-correction eye cream, this targets multiple signs of aging to reveal a more youthful, glowing, and brighter eye area. This also effectively targets eye dryness and dark circles for a healthier area around the eyes. This also works in fighting against early signs of aging to maintain a youthful look longer.

Formulated with the ingredient narcissus bulb, this helps maintain and protect your skin’s barrier to improve elasticity to actively reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines. The safflower oleosomes, being a natural source of vitamin E, helps deliver intense moisture and hydration to smooth out the skin’s roughness and dryness for a plumper look and feel all over your eye area. The buckwheat wax in its pool and wonderful ingredients also helps reduce the appearance of puffiness around the eye’s delicate area.

With this Tata Harper eye cream in your skincare routine whether in the morning or at night, you can rest assured that this will help smooth out any contours appearing on the eye area all the while brightening the complexion and minimizing dark circles that can often make you look tired and aged. Your skin is sure to soak and absorb this right up and will leave your eyes feeling good throughout the day without feeling oily or greasy. This is also effective in smoothing out rough eyelids, getting them ready for a smooth and seamless eye makeup application.

Overall, this makes you achieve a more youthful appearance by actively fighting early signs of aging all the while eliminating dark circles around your eyes. There is a pleasant light scent to it, though it’s not up to everyone’s taste. With 15 sources to plump intense hydration and moisture, 10 sources to minimize the multiple signs of aging, and 5 sources to reduce the appearance of puffy eyes, you can trust this to provide you with all-around care targeting the delicate area of the eyes.

A hundred percent of its ingredients come from natural origin while 48% of the ingredients are organically-sourced. This is completely non-toxic and free from filters, synthetics, and artificial colors and fragrances, so you can be sure that you only get the best in the market. With this option, you will never have to choose between quality results and health ever again. Keep in mind too that this can be on the pricier end of things so make sure you are ready for the splurge before proceeding.


  • Ideal anti-aging eye cream
  • Reveals a youthful, glowing, and brighter eye area
  • Targets dryness and dark circles around eyes
  • Improves skin’s barrier and elasticity
  • Reduces appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, and signs of aging
  • Deeply hydrates and moisturizes eyes
  • Helps reduce puffy eye area
  • Smooths out eye contours
  • Soaks and absorbs right in without feeling oily or greasy
  • Pleasant light scent
  • 100% natural origin and 48% organic origin
  • Free from toxins, filter, synthetics, and artificial colors and fragrance


  • Scent is not for everyone
  • Can be a bit pricey

4. Beauty by Earth Coffee Bean Eye Cream

Beauty by Earth Coffee Bean Eye Cream

The Beauty by Earth Coffee Bean Eye Cream is our next favorite organic eye cream! Another caffeine eye cream, this helps reduce the appearance of bags and dark circles around your eye area due to lack of sleep and tiredness. This also minimizes the puffiness and appearance of signs of premature aging and promotes a deeply moisturized and hydrated eye area. By including this in your daily skincare routine, you are sure to free your eyes from the appearance of just having woken up and give it a much needed lift and life to get you started on your day.

Infused with nourishing ingredients like coffee bean extracts, organic oils, aloe vera, and cucumber to name a few, this is sure to soothe and nourish your eye’s delicate and sensitive area. Its formula has also been packed with anti-inflammatory and anti-aging benefits so you are sure to keep early signs of aging away from your eyes for as long as you can. Every drop of this coffee bean eye cream will provide much-needed moisture along your eyes to keep them looking bright, glowing, and awake.

This Beauty by Earth eye cream has a light herbal scent to it instead of an awakening coffee scent you would usually expect. Keep in mind though that not all users have been a big fan of the naturally-occurring scent this comes with. Using this every morning or even at night will make your eyes feel more awake and energized instantly. This absorbs well into your skin and wears and layers well under makeup. It has a nice consistency that is deeply moisturizing yet doesn’t leave you feeling oily and greasy at all.

And to ensure that you only get the best of the best with this eye cream, only clean and healthy ingredients have been used to make this. There are no toxic ingredients to potentially harm your skin and this hasn’t been tested on animals so you can keep your peace of mind as you are applying this along your eyes.


  • Caffeine eye cream that helps reduce dark circles
  • Reduces appearance of puffiness and premature signs of aging
  • Gives morning eyes much-needed lift
  • Deeply moisturizes and hydrates eye area
  • Soothes and nourishes eye’s delicate area
  • Anti-inflammatory and anti-aging benefits
  • Keeps eyes bright, glowing, and awake
  • Eyes feel awake and energized
  • Absorbs well into skin and wears well under makeup
  • Non-oily and non-greasy formula
  • Clean and healthy ingredients without toxins
  • Cruelty-free


  • Scent is not for everyone

5. Nourish Organic Renewing & Hydrating Eye Treatment

Nourish Organic Renewing & Hydrating Eye Treatment

The last item on our picks for the best organic eye creams is the Nourish Organic Renewing & Hydrating Eye Treatment! This certified organic eye cream promises to refresh and hydrate your eyes as it depuffs so they appear firmer, brighter, and more awake to get you through the day. Formulated with plant-based ingredients, this tube of eye cream promises to help increase your eye’s hydration so you are able to achieve smoother under eyes with minimized appearance of puffiness.

Formulated with soothing and nourishing ingredients like avocado oil and Moroccan argan oil, this is sure to provide the delicate area around your eyes with much-needed moisture and hydration. Every time you use this as part of your skin care routine, you are able to rejuvenate and renew the skin around your eyes so they can appear with a pleasant glow and brighter than ever before. The consistency of the cream can be thick enough to provide deep moisture, but fear not as it absorbs rather fast and feels light against the skin and not heavy or greasy at all.

The brand’s Organic Certification guarantees its loyal users that the ingredients used to make this eye cream, along with many of the brand’s products, have been organically and sustainably grown without the use of harmful chemicals and pesticides. You are assured that you are only putting clean and healthy ingredients on your skin. The formula doesn’t contain parabens, sulfates, silicones, artificial colors and fragrances, and other toxins – assuring you that this is safe for use on sensitive skin.

On top of being a clean, organic, and safe product, the brand Nourish Organic is a proud member of the 1% For The Planet where they have pledged 1% of all their profits to directly go to key environmental initiatives. This is also cruelty-free, making sure you are able to sleep peacefully at night, knowing that you do good not only for your skin but also for the environment.


  • Refreshes and hydrates eye area
  • Smoother under eye area with decreased puffiness
  • Deeply moisturizes and hydrates delicate under eye area
  • Rejuvenates and renews tired-looking eyes
  • Provides eyes with glow and are brighter
  • Absorbs well into skin and layers well under makeup
  • No oily or greasy feeling left behind
  • All ingredients have been organically and sustainably grown
  • No harmful chemicals or pesticides were used for the ingredients
  • No parabens, silicones, sulfates, and other toxins
  • 1% of the profit goes directly to environmental initiatives


  • None

How to Choose the Best Organic Eye Cream

With so many eye cream options consumers can freely choose from right now, it’s important to know what factors to look for to make sure you get exactly what your eyes need.

Eye concerns

The first thing you’d want to be considering in looking for your new organic eye cream are your eye concerns. Not everyone deals with the same eye issues and not all eye creams are formulated to address all eye issues and concerns. Determine what eye concerns you’d want to be addressed and make sure to get an eye cream that can help you with your concern. Whether your problem lies with puffiness, dark circles, dry under eyes, or signs of aging, you are sure to find an eye cream that fits the criteria you’re looking for.


When switching to organic skincare or to an organic product, it’s important to always take a look and read the ingredients list. Remember, it’s not enough to believe the sign or word at the label that says ‘organic’. Make sure to read through its list of ingredients so you can be sure that it is indeed organic. Also take note of how the ingredients are grown and harvested.

Price point

The last thing you would want to keep an eye out for is the organic eye cream’s price point. Eye creams come at a variety of price ranges. Whether you’d want to splurge on your next eye cream or would want to get something that’s sure to be effective yet won’t burn a whole through your wallet should play a role in your decision process. Ask yourself at what price range you’re willing to go for so you can take some options off that don’t meet the criteria, making the decision process easier for you.


The eyes are the windows to the soul – and that is exactly why we all should start considering a little something to better take care of them. And what’s better than an organic eye cream, right?

Our number one pick for the best organic eye cream is the 100% Pure Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream thanks to its all-around formula that reduces the appearance of puffiness and dark circles while minimizing the appearance of various signs of aging! It also helps increase hydration and moisture around the eye area for eyes that look youthful, dewy, fresh, and bright all over! If what you’re looking for is an organic eye cream that can provide intense hydration and moisture around the eye area, you might want to check out the Spirit Nest The Sage Witch Eye Cream! This boasts of a deep moisturizing formula that isn’t oily or greasy while providing much-needed deep nourishment. And the Tata Harper Restorative Eye Crème is our pick for the best anti-aging eye cream thanks to its formula that improves skin’s barrier and elasticity! This will help you say goodbye to early signs of aging around your eye area.

We hope our list of our current favorites and guide above led you to your new favorite organic eye cream. Here’s to you and your healthy eyes!

Related Articles