Best Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes

Best Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes featured photo

If you’re currently on the hunt for the best eyeshadow for blue eyes that’s out in the market you can easily get your hands on right now, be sure to check on a few important factors first: where and when you will use it, the applicator, the finish, and whether it’s a single eyeshadow or a palette. I have searched for the best of the best with these factors in mind and have them all listed and reviewed below. If you want to find out what made the cut of my current favorites, be sure to read along with me!

Eyeshadow and eyeshadow palettes were one of the first few makeup products I ever owned. Wearing and applying eyeshadow can make or break my entire makeup look and ensemble for the day. Through years of makeup curiosity, I learned that it’s important to consider where I’m going and what I’m wearing in deciding on eyeshadow colors and palettes to apply. Carefully choosing the colors for my eyes also matters a lot as I have a darker skin tone and as a personal preference, would like to wear certain colors and shades.

No one can really tell you or me what eyeshadow color we should wear or what we shouldn’t wear. It’s all up to personal preference and style. But if you’re like me who likes to be extra careful of colors and shades – and not just with makeup! – basic color theory can help in determining what eyeshadow shades and palettes will help your blue eyes – whether they’re light blue or dark blue – pop! Lucky for you, I have the best listed below so you wouldn’t have to look further.

If you’re ready to find out what my current favorite eyeshadows for beautiful blue eyes are, go ahead and scroll along!

What Eyeshadow Colors Look Best on Blue Eyes?

Blue eye of a woman close-up photo

Generally, anyone with any eye color can wear any eyeshadow color and shade possible as long as they are happy with it. But if you want that extra pop for your blue eyes, you can always choose colors and shades that will help you achieve just that.

Browns and nudes are always a good choice for anyone with any eye color. These eyeshadow colors provide a more natural and subtle eye makeup but still complements the blue shades of your eyes. You can also use a wide array of nude and brown shades to achieve a smokey eye effect. Most nudes and browns flatter different shades of blue eyes, so you can never go wrong with those when used with blue eyes.

Going back to color wheel and theory, colors on the opposite side of blue on the color wheel effectively creates contrast that will help emphasize the blue in your eyes, drawing attention to them. If that is what you’re going for, a variety of orange shades might just do the trick. Colors with varying warm orange tones will contrast blue eyes and will bring forth the certain ‘pop’ you’re looking for. These oranges don’t necessarily have to be bright shades per se. If you aren’t sure yet if you can pull off bright shades of orange yet, you can also opt for orange-based hues like copper, coral, bronze, coral, or peach.

If you’re feeling extra daring when it comes to playing around with eyeshadow colors, you can choose shades of purple or green as they are sure to complement whatever shade of blue eyes – whether light blue eyes or gray blue eyes. Cool lilacs and warm metals are also sure to help make eyes pop. You can also go for eyeshadows with shimmery finishes to give your eyes that extra glitz and glamor.

Some blue-eyed babes and beauties can also attest to how the right tone of blue eyeshadow can actually complement your hue of blue eyes. Using varied shades of light blue or dark blue eyeshadow can actually give your eyes a more vibrant and bright appearance. When it comes to blue eyeshadows for blue eyes, it’s important that you choose a blue hue that will make eyes pop.

Our Top Picks for the Best Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our PickToo Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow PaletteToo Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow PaletteCheck Price
Best for Bold MakeupRevlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Big BangRevlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Big BangCheck Price
Best Budget-FriendlyRimmel Magnif'eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nude EditionRimmel Magnif’eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nude EditionCheck Price
Julep Eyeshadow Stick, Taupe ShimmerJulep Eyeshadow Stick, Taupe ShimmerCheck Price
Urban Decay Eyeshadow Compact, SinUrban Decay Eyeshadow Compact, SinCheck Price

The Best Eyeshadow for Blue Eyes

1. Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow Palette – Our Pick!

Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow Palette

Our top pick for the best eyeshadow and palette for blue eyes is the Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow Palette! An 18-pan eyeshadow palette, this offers a variety of shades and finishes that will certainly complement those with blue eyes. This is one of the best eyeshadow palettes for blue eyes and is full of warm and spicy colors with inspiration from the flavors and colors of Christmas. Ranging from warm to smoldering shades, this will definitely help the shades of blue in your eyes pop more with every swipe and with every layer.

The Too Faced eyeshadow palette is made up of shades with both matte and shimmery finishes and you are sure you won’t run out of shades and colors to choose from. Every hue allows you to achieve either rich and warm daytime makeup looks and smoldering nighttime looks. Each palette offers users a broad collection of shades and colors that allow for much versatility in achieving a varied ray of makeup looks for every day and night. It’s composed of sheer to highly-pigmented shades that allow for a variety of eye makeup looks.

The orange tones and hues of some of the palette’s shades will provide great eyeshadow looks for blue eyes as these can provide a contrast that will help make the blue pop out and bring more attention to them. It also has some nice browns and peaches in the palette you can conveniently use for daily makeup looks and achieve a more neutral and natural finish. And if you ever want to give yourself some shimmer under lights whether during the day or night, this offers some impressive shades with shimmer as well.

The Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow Palette is known for smelling like freshly-baked goods on a Christmas morning. And no worries, the scent only lasts upon opening the palette and will not stick around as you apply it as part of your makeup routine. You are also promised that every shade blends well and offers great pigment with just one swipe.

Keep in mind though that the color payoff of some shades may not be as vibrant on darker complexions and would need more layers to achieve your desired eyeshadow looks. Other than that, this offers a wide variety of shades that will surely look great on blue eyes. The brand is also certified cruelty-free, so if that is something important to you and your products, be sure to check this one out.

Pros:

  • Warm and spicy shades
  • Versatile palette and shades for a variety of looks
  • Matte and shimmery finishes
  • 18-pan eyeshadow palette
  • Orange tones make blue eyes pop
  • Sheer to highly-pigmented shades and warmer tones
  • Has a number of rich browns and neutrals
  • Smells like freshly-baked goods
  • Blends well and great color payoff
  • Great for natural to smoldering makeup looks
  • Cruelty-free

Cons:

  • Some shades may be sheer and needs more layers

2. Revlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Big Bang – Best for Bold Makeup!

Revlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Big Bang

Our next favorite eyeshadow for blue eyes and our pick for the best for bold makeup is the Revlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette, The Big Bang! If what you’re looking for is an eyeshadow palette that can help you achieve bold eyeshadow looks for blue eyes that will surely complement, be sure to check this one out. Consisting of 4 crystal-like pigments, you can easily combine the colors that are sure to go well together to achieve that smoldering and bold makeup look you’re going for.

The Revlon eyeshadow palette promises you very bright and vibrant pigments with shimmery finish to give your eyes not just the pop it needs, but a sparkling pop it needs. Each shade gives you a rich and highly-pigmented color payoff. The palette also makes it easier for you to choose colors that will definitely go well together when mixed and blended – a must for absolute beginners. The gold, pink, copper, and brown shimmery shades are sure to go well with your blue eyes and will bring further attention to them.

Designed with a suspended gel technology, this eyeshadow palette from Revlon provides a bouncy texture without fallout. This applies nicely and glides on easily as you apply it on your lids. It has also been formulated to be long-lasting and remains without creasing and smudging as it stays put where you put it on application. It’s also been formulated with crystal-like pigments for multidimensional colors. This promises long-lasting wear and stays on all day or all night that are extremely flattering for your blue eyes.

One downside you should know regarding this eyeshadow palette, as shared by users, is that some shades on some people might require a few more layers than some to be able to achieve that bright and vibrant pigment for certain eyeshadow looks. Other than this minor downside, this is an overall quality eyeshadow palette that will surely make your blue eyes pop even more.

Pros:

  • Ideal for bold makeup looks
  • Complements blue eyes well
  • 4 complementary shades in one
  • Bright and vibrant pigments
  • Rich and highly-pigmented shades
  • Ease of choosing colors that go well
  • Blends and applies well
  • Long-lasting and all-day wearing formula
  • No smudging, creasing, or fading
  • Crystal-like finish

Cons:

  • Some shades may need more layers for high pigment

3. Rimmel Magnif’eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nude Edition – Best Budget-Friendly!

Rimmel Magnif'eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nude Edition

The next item that made it into our list of the best eyeshadow for blue eyes and our top budget-friendly option is the Rimmel Magnif’eyes Eyeshadow Palette, Nude Edition! If you’re new to the eyeshadow scene and are looking for a budget-friendly palette to get you started on your journey, you might want to check this one out. The 12-pan palette is an all-in-one eyeshadow, liner, and highlighter in one palette. Shades vary from shimmer to matte finishes you can freely choose from for a variety of eyeshadow looks for blue eyes.

The Rimmel eyeshadow palette allows you to play around with each shade to achieve a variety of makeup looks – from natural and bare to bold and smokey eye makeup. You also get a good number of nudes and browns with warm tones that are perfect for daily and professional makeup looks. And you know what they say, you can never go wrong with browns and nudes – even our blue-eyed beauties! You also get a mix of sophisticated shades of beige, taupe, and coffee to accompany you from day to night.

Each shade in the Rimmel promises to remain crease proof and smudge proof as long as you wear it. Do keep in mind that some shades may not be as long-wearing as one would hope., but this isn’t something priming your lids and setting the product wouldn’t help with. Just remember that if you choose to go with this one, make sure to take extra steps to keep the same quality and color throughout the day. 

This eyeshadow palette offers a nice assortment and mix of versatile shades with matte and shimmer finishes for your blue eyes. You can easily and conveniently mix and match the shades to achieve your desired look as they blend fairly well. This is also a great and inexpensive choice for beginners to have something to play around and experiment with before jumping onto more expensive and pricier makeup brands.

Pros:

  • Ideal budget option
  • 12-pan eyeshadow palette
  • Eyeshadow, liner, and highlighter in one
  • Shimmer and matte finishes
  • Good mix of browns, nudes, and warm shades
  • Achieve subtle natural to bold smokey eye makeup looks
  • Crease and smudge proof
  • Versatile set of shades for day and night looks
  • All the shades are blended well
  • Great beginner palette with warm neutrals

Cons:

  • Not as long-lasting

4. Julep Eyeshadow Stick, Taupe Shimmer

Julep Eyeshadow Stick, Taupe Shimmer

Our next favorite eyeshadow for blue eyes is the Julep Eyeshadow Stick in Taupe Shimmer! This single stick eyeshadow offers a shimmery gray-brown pigment that gives its users natural-looking makeup looks but with a chic update. This one also complements those with blue eyes as it contrasts the shades of blue while adding shimmer with every swipe. Your shade of blue eyes also appear to be wider and brighter with this in your daily makeup routine.

Formulated with Vitamins C and E, every swipe of this Julep eyeshadow stick promises to treat and protect your eyelids from environmental damage and free radicals. These also make the formula hydrating and nourishing as it offers color and shimmer. The formula is also infused with candelilla wax so the sticks allow for easy application and blending. This is also proudly formulated to be waterproof for a long-lasting, all-day wear without creasing, smudging, or fading no matter how long you choose to wear it.

The eyeshadow stick comes with a built-in smudger for effortless blending without the need for a separate brush or applicator. This allows for an extremely fast and no-brainer application. A cream to powder stick, this applies like a cream – smooth and even – and finishes like a powder. It also has just the right amount of shimmer to it that is never too much of a sparkle. A quick reminder that this can wear off fast on oily lids if not primed and set the right way, so remember to do just that with this one.

If you want a totally waterproof eyeshadow that only wears off until you decide to take it off, be sure to check this one out. You also don’t need to reapply your eyeshadow with this in your makeup routine, though the stick packaging makes it a lot easier for you to carry it around in your bag. You can use this along your lower lash line or upper lash line. Using this on the outer corner or the inner corner of your eyes will also help highlight your eyes.

Pros:

  • Stick eyeshadow
  • Complements blue eyes
  • Shimmer finish
  • Truly waterproof formula
  • All-day and long-wearing formula
  • Hydrating and nourishing on the eyelids
  • No creasing, smudging, or fading
  • Fast and easy application
  • Built-in smudger for easy blending
  • Smooth and even application

Cons:

  • Can wear off on oily lids if not set or primed

5. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Compact, Sin

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Compact, Sin

The last item on our list of the best and our favorite eyeshadows for blue eyes is the Urban Decay Eyeshadow Compact in Sin! This eyeshadow offers a pale nude pigment with a shimmer finish that goes well on blue eyes if what you’re trying to achieve is a natural eyeshadow for everyday look that can still bring attention to them. If you’re not ready to dive into bold colors and eye looks just yet, this is definitely a good way to as a daily color for your blue eyes.

With a pigment infusion system, this Urban Decay eyeshadow promises highly-pigmented results that easily glides and applies on your eyelids. It also offers a shimmer finish but isn’t overly sparkly so you can still use it everyday in a professional setting. The formula goes on buttery smooth with hardly any fallout. This shade works really well by itself for everyday wear or blended with other shades to achieve a variety of eye makeup looks when you feel like dressing up.

This compact eyeshadow assures you of its all-day and long-wearing formula even without a primer – though adding a primer before this can always be a good idea. This goes on really smooth and blends well by itself or with other eyeshadow products. Urban Decay is also proudly cruelty-free and doesn’t test its products on animals. If that is something of major importance to you, you might want to give this one a try.

Pros:

  • Pale nude pigment with shimmer finish
  • Great for natural eyeshadow for daily look
  • Works well by itself or with other eyeshadows
  • Versatile enough for bold makeup looks
  • Highly-pigmented results
  • Applies buttery smooth and blends well
  • No product fallout
  • All-day wearing formula
  • Cruelty-free

Cons:

  • None

Eyeshadow Application Tips and Tricks

A few application tips and tricks will make sure you achieve your desired look along with your desired product longevity. Read on below for some tips and tricks we’ve gathered to make sure you get the most of your new eyeshadow!

Make blue eyes pop

The first tip we have for you is to find the best eyeshadow colors not only for your makeup needs but something that will complement your eye color. If you’re still on the fence on deciding whether or not a hue is the right one for blue eyes, check out our list and review of our favorites above to see if you find one that is up to your liking. The best eyeshadow colors for blue eyes will help enhance and complement.

Use a primer

Whether you have oily lids or not, you should always consider priming your eyelids before applying your eyeshadow. This will give you a smoother eyeshadow base and will help give your eyeshadow a longer life on your eyelids no matter what activities you have planned for the day.

Use the right brush

The key to achieving the perfect eye makeup look you’re going for is using the right tools and brushes, it’s not only enough that you have the best eyeshadow in hand. You’d want to make sure you have a basic eyeshadow brush, a blending brush, and an angled brush – especially if you plan on blending and mixing an assortment of shades. Having the right tools will ensure you apply the eyeshadow well and evenly.

Eyeshadow before foundation

In doing your makeup routine, you would want to apply your eyeshadow first before your foundation. The reason behind this is so that you can easily remove and brush off any fallout from your eyeshadow. If it isn’t possible for you to apply eyeshadow before foundation, make sure you use a tissue or napkin to catch the fallout and prevent it from making contact with your skin.

Blend eyeshadow

With eyeshadow application, you want to make sure you blend the product well and evenly. It’s especially important if you have different shades and products layered on your eyelids. Also make sure you do both your eyelids evenly.

Use your crease

Another great tip in eyeshadow application is to define your crease and use it as your guide. Working your eyeshadow along your eyes’ crease will help add more depth and make sure the color is visible whenever you have your eyes open.

How to Choose the Best Eyeshadow for Blue Eyes

Below are some factors for you to consider to make sure you only get the best eyeshadow and the eyeshadow colors for blue eyes that will help enhance their natural beauty.

Where and when you will use it

One of the first things you should be considering in looking for your new eyeshadow is the where and when you will be wearing the eyeshadow. Are you looking for a natural-looking eyeshadow for daily wear or an eyeshadow that will get you through glam and night outs? Ask yourself this question so you can easily narrow down eyeshadow choices.

Applicator

Some eyeshadows come with applicators or brushes while others don’t. If you don’t have your own set of eyeshadow brushes to use, make sure to consider getting one that comes with an applicator. If you do have your own tools, a built-in or free applicator is up to your personal choice.

Finish

Eyehsadows can come in satin, matte, or shimmer finishes. Satin finish eyeshadows give a more natural look and finish. Matte finishes eliminate all shine on your eyelids while shimmer finishes glow and sparkle just the right amount for that extra glitz and glamor. Ask yourself what finish you would prefer to wear and get something along that preference. 

Single or palette

Eyeshadows are often sold in single shades or palettes for a variety of different shades. Ask yourself what you would prefer to get from your eyeshadow. Single eyeshadows are great for those who only need a certain color, while a palette is a good choice for someone who wants to have a variety of shade choices in just a single pack

Conclusion

If you want to bring even more attention to your eyes and make blue eyes pop every day, eyeshadows can do exactly that.

Our number one pick for the best eyeshadow for blue eyes is the Too Faced Gingerbread Extra Spicy Eyeshadow Palette thanks to its versatile set of shades of oranges, browns, and shimmers that will certainly complement and bring out the blue in your eyes! This also allows you to achieve a variety of makeup looks from natural to bold. If what you’re looking for is an eyeshadow palette that is sure to give you bold makeup looks every single time, you should check out Revlon So Fierce! Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette in The Big Bang. And the Rimmel Magnif’eyes Eyeshadow Palette in Nude Edition is our number one pick for the best budget-friendly eyeshadow. This is especially a great option for beginners to start experimenting around with!

We hope you were able to find your new favorite eyeshadow for blue eyes from our list above. Happy makeup shopping!

Related Articles