Best Eyeliner for Watery Eyes

Best Eyeliner for Watery Eyes featured photo

If you’re on the lookout for the best eyeliner for watery eyes you can get your hands on at this very moment, be sure you stop and consider a few important things before going ahead with your choice: waterproof formula factor, the type of eyeliner, the finish, and ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested factor. Lucky for you and me both, I found the best of the best in the market right now and I have them all listed and reviewed just below. If you’re ready to find out what made the cut and how the factors I mentioned played their parts, go ahead and just read along!

As far as I can remember, I’ve always had sensitive and sometimes even watery eyes. I get allergies easily and my eyes could start watering. Because of this, I’m not one to regularly wear eyeliner as part of my makeup routine. When I wear the wrong eyeliner and I get the usual allergies along with watery eyes, it would just end up smudging and ruin my overall look I put effort into achieving.

For years, I’ve sworn off using eyeliners as a whole. Recently, though, as I scroll through Instagram, I am welcomed with so many makeup looks that can be achieved when added with eyeliner. Thus, I begin my research of the best eyeliner that can withstand watery eyes, eye sensitivities, and my seasonal allergies. Luckily, I’m not the only person in this journey and other people’s experiences with a lot of eyeliner products have been of great help.

If you’re eager more than ever to find out what made it into my favorites list, get ready as I list them all down below!

What are Watery Eyes and What Causes Them?

Before we head on to my list of favorites out in the market right now, let’s first try to understand watery eyes and what causes eyes to water as many people experience.

Watery eyes simply mean that our eyes and tear ducts produce tears in excessive amounts, and when you produce too much tears, your tear ducts can get overwhelmed and you develop watery eyes. Generally speaking, watery eyes don’t call for too much concern but can be a bother when applying makeup products, especially an eyeliner.

Watery eyes can be caused by a number of reasons. You can temporarily have watery eyes when you are emotional, laughing hard, or yawning. One of the most common causes of watery eyes are dry eyes, as ironic as it sounds. When your eyes don’t receive enough water and oils, your eyes dry up fast. As a response to the irritation of dry eyes, your body will produce excess tears, starting and continuing the cycle. Allergies and colds are common reasons to develop watery eyes. Any kind of eye inflammation can also cause your eyes to water excessively.

Watery eyes can also be more prevalent as we age. When you have watery eyes, it’s understandable that you go through a lot of trials and errors in eye makeup to find your holy grail products that will surely stay put no matter what.

Our Top Picks for the Best Eyeliners for Watery Eyes

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our PickStila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid EyelinerStila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye LinerCheck Price
Best for Intense and Dramatic LooksMaybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel EyelinerMaybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel EyelinerCheck Price
Best Bang for Your BuckRevlon ColorStay EyelinerRevlon ColorStay EyelinerCheck Price
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel PencilRimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel PencilCheck Price
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye PencilUrban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye PencilCheck Price

The Best Eyeliner for Watery Eyes

1. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner – Our Pick!

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Our top and favorite pick for the best eyeliner for watery eyes is the cult-favorite Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner! A waterproof eyeliner, this promises to stay put on your lids all day even through excess watery eyes. With this liquid liner formula in your makeup routine, you are sure to achieve a variety of eyeliner looks from thin and precise to thick and dramatic any day. This promises a no smudge and a no run formula that stays in place until you take it off at the end of the day.

The fine marker-like felt tip applicator of this Stila’s Stay All Day eyeliner offers crazy precision during application – a huge, huge plus whether you are a beginner or a makeup pro. With this in your hands, you are assured that application is easy and efficient, whether you’re going for a subtle, thin line for a softer look or a thick, perfect wing or cat eye along your lids and lash line. The tip also glides on with much ease on your eyelids, without skipping or pulling so you get the perfect line and result every single time. The formula itself dries quickly and is transfer-free once it has completely dried.

If you’re someone who has completely given up on all eyeliner because of your watery eyes, you might want to check this one out as this stays on very well – yes, even on watery eyes! This is also formulated to resist through hot and humid weather, so no matter where you are, you can put your trust on this one. This lasts all day until you take it off, though keep in mind that some might experience that it doesn’t come off easily with just soap and water – but a makeup remover shall do the trick. And no worries, this doesn’t leave any residue and takes off well.

The Stay All Day eyeliner has been ophthalmologist-tested and is safe for use by those with sensitive eyes and non-irritating for contact lense wearers. The waterproof eyeliner is currently available in 8 shades: intense balck, dark brown, intense smoky quartz, intense labradorite, midnight, alloy, intense, and snow for all your makeup needs. This one offers a satin to shiny ultra-smooth finish to it as well.

Another thing users have mentioned in reviews is to be careful in putting the cap back and putting it back the wrong way can actually damage the fine felt tip of the eyeliner, so just keep that in mind if you decide to go with this one. Overall, this is a popular choice whether you’re a makeup artist or simply an enthusiast and will surely help you avoid raccoon eyes altogether!

Pros:

  • Stays put on watery eyes
  • Waterproof and all-day wearing formula
  • Precise and easy application for thin or thick lines
  • Available in 8 shades
  • Satin to shiny finish
  • Great for winged lines
  • Doesn’t smudge, run, or transfer
  • Quick-drying formula
  • No pulling, tugging, or skipping
  • Resists hot and humid weather
  • Ophthalmologist-tested – sensitive and contact lense safe
  • Takes off well – no residue

Cons:

  • Difficult to remove with just soap and water

2. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner – Best for Intense and Dramatic Looks!

Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner

The next item that made it into our list of the best eyeliner for watery eyes and our choice for intense and dramatic looks is the Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner from beauty brand Maybelline New York! If what you’re looking for is a dramatic liner that will allow you to achieve intense and bold eyes every time you whip it out, be sure to check this one out. A waterproof and long-lasting gel formula infused with highly-concentrated pigments, this is sure to give you dramatic eye looks for all-day lasting drama.

The Maybelline New York gel liner is an oil-free formula that promises smudge and waterproof results that lasts for a whopping 24 hours! The brand’s most intense liner yet, this boasts of a highly-pigmented result with a matte finish. The formula glides on with much ease on your lids and lash line and sets quickly. Once set where you applied it, it promises to stay exactly there without smearing or smudging, even on watery eyes! It has a buildable formula that goes on smoothly and easily and allows you to apply layer on top of layer.

The Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner comes in a jar and comes with a brush for easy application. The brush applicator allows for precise application whether you’re going for a thin or a thicker line. It also allows you to achieve very defined lines, it doesn’t matter whether you’re a beginner or a professional. One pot of this gel liner is definitely worth the price you pay for it as it can last you for about 6 months or so. It’s currently available in 3 shades: blackest black, brown, and charcoal for all your makeup needs.

The gel liner has been ophthalmologist, dermatologist, and allergy-tested and is completely safe to use for sensitive eyes and those who regularly wear contact lenses. The waterproof and smudge proof gel liner can be difficult to remove with just soap and water so make sure you use your favorite makeup remover. Once removed with the right product, this one doesn’t leave behind any residue on your lids.

Pros:

  • Ideal for intense and dramatic looks
  • Stays intact on watery eyes
  • Available in 3 shades
  • Matte finish
  • Smudge and waterproof formula
  • Highly pigmented results
  • Comes with brush applicator
  • One jar can last for months
  • No smearing or smudging once set and dry
  • Quick-drying formula
  • Ophthalmologist, dermatologist, and allergy-tested
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • No residue left behind

Cons:

  • Needs makeup remover to remove

3. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner – Best Bang for Your Buck!

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

Our next favorite eyeliner for watery eyes is the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner – also the best bang for your buck! If what you’re searching for is a budget-friendly eyeliner that will not compromise results and its staying power on watery eyes, read on to learn more about this one. The waterproof and smudge proof eyeliner promises a long-wearing formula that stays put without fading even with extremely watery eyes. This promises to stay put and intact where you put it for about 24 hours as well.

The Revlon eyeliner is dual-sided with the liner on one end and a built-in sharpener and built-in smudger on the other end – talk about getting what you paid for, right? The sharpener comes in very handy when you want to achieve an ultra-fin tip for sharp and precise lines whether you’re going for thin and subtle or winged and dramatic. You can also conveniently use the built-in smudger to achieve a smokey and smoldering eye look whenever you feel like it.

If you’ve had constant issues with a lot of eyeliners that don’t stay put on your watery eyes, you might want to consider this one as this doesn’t come off or smudge on watery eyes at all. This promises to not smear, smudge, or fade even on bad allergy days. The formula of the eyeliner applies and glides on smoothly and easily and stays where you put it without moving. With this waterproof Revlon eyeliner in your makeup routine, you are sure to achieve precise and dramatic lines for a variety of eye makeup looks for days.

The Revlon eyeliner has been ophthalmologist-tested, assuring that it is safe for use on sensitive eyes and for those who wear contacts. This offers a matte finish and is currently available in a variety of 8 shades: black, black violet, sapphire, black brown, charcoal, teal, brown, and jade for all your makeup needs for all occasions.

One downside users have shared regarding the product is that the tip can easily break off so make sure you handle and apply with care to avoid easy breakage. Aside from that, this is an overall quality eyeliner that works and does what it claims at an inexpensive price.

Pros:

  • Ideal budget eyeliner
  • Stays put on watery eyes without fading or smearing
  • Waterproof and smudge proof formula
  • Has built-in sharpener and smudge tip on one end
  • Great for thin and precise line or smokey and smoldering look
  • Available in 8 shades
  • Matte finish
  • Waterproof and all-day wearing formula
  • Ophthalmologist-tested – safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Smooth and easy application

Cons:

  • Tip can break off easily

4. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil

The Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eyebrow Pencil from beauty brand Rimmel is the next item that made it into our list of the best eyeliners for watery eyes! This is another great choice for those with watery eyes as this is a waterproof formula that won’t run or smudge throughout the day. This doesn’t move from where you put it on your eyelids unless you say it’s time to go. The eyeliner has also been formulated to withstand sweat, heat, and humidity so you are sure to end the day with the same eyeliner quality you started with.

Aside from an all-day wear formula, this also offers very pigmented results with every swipe. It also has a soft and creamy texture that glides off easily for smooth and seamless application. It’s very easy to apply that you wouldn’t need to put in too much effort as it’s very easy to work with. This promises to last all day and not move an inch until you take it off yourself. It’s also fairly easy to take off at the end of the day and wouldn’t require much effort from you.

The Rimmel eyeliner has been dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested. It has proven that this is safe for use on sensitive eyes and those who regularly wear contact lenses. There are currently 5 available shades you can freely choose from: black, sparkling black, brown, deep blue, and nude. Depending on the shade you choose to get, you get a variety of finishes from matte to shiny to satin.

If you choose to go for this Rimmel waterproof liner, do keep in mind that extremely watery eyes might still need to touch-up, though very seldom compared to other liners. You also would need to sharpen this frequently as the texture is soft and would need frequent resharpening. Overall, this is another quality and inexpensive eyeliner option that does what it claims.

Pros:

  • Waterproof formula
  • Stays put on watery eyes
  • No running or smudging throughout the day
  • Soft and creamy texture
  • Glides on smoothly and easily
  • Texture is easy to apply and work with
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Available in 5 shades with varying finishes
  • Easy to remove and take off

Cons:

  • Extremely watery eyes may need seldom touch-ups
  • Soft texture might need frequent resharpening

5. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Urban Decay 24-7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

The last item that made it into our list of our favorite eyeliners is the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil! This is a waterproof eyeliner that promises long-wear formula with an intense color payoff that won’t smudge or budge throughout the day. This doesn’t come off until you say it’s time to go at the end of the day. Even on watery eyes, this is sure to stay put and stay intact, allowing you to end your day with the intense pigment as if it has just been applied.

Formulated with vitamin E, jojoba oil, and cottonseed oil, this Urban Decay eyeliner does not only allow you to achieve a variety of eye makeup looks but also an all-around hydrating formula. Each swipe promises to hydrate, moisturize, and condition your eyelids every time you whip this one out for your makeup routine. The ultra-creamy formula applies and glides on smoothly and easily allowing you to achieve seamless and precise lines every single time. The formula also stays soft on lids for about 30 seconds for blending for a smokey look.

The Urban Decay eyeliner is available in a whopping 26 shades for all your makeup needs. The eyeliner finish varies from matte, cream, shimmer, metallic, and glitter. This has been formulated without parabens and certified cruelty-free for your peace of mind while using. The line also offers shades that are completely vegan for those who would prefer that in their eyeliner. This one also doesn’t bother sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.

Though on the expensive side in the world of eyeliners, the pencil is sure to last you a long time and is well worth the price you paid for it. If what you’re looking for is a high-end and on the pricier side eyeliner that boasts of a formula that will stay intact even on watery eyes, be sure to add this on your list of liners to consider.

Pros:

  • Waterproof and all-day wearing formula
  • Stays put on watery eyes without smudging
  • Intense color payoff
  • Available in 26 shades with a variety of finishes
  • Hydrating, moisturizing, and conditioning formula
  • Paraben and cruelty-free
  • Available vegan shades
  • Allows for blending and smudging
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Pencil lasts for a long time

Cons:

  • A bit expensive

Tips & Tricks – Eyeliner Application for Watery Eyes

If you have watery eyes and have experienced constant issues with applying eye makeup, we have below some tips and tricks in applying eyeliner and other eye products.

Use eye drops

If you know that there is something bothering your eyes, you may opt to use an eye drop before applying your makeup. This helps in getting rid of small particles bothering your eyes and could moisturize your eyes in the process as well. This could also help get rid of any discomfort your eyes are experiencing.

Hypoallergenic is the way to go

You can also always go for hypoallergenic products. By doing so, you are making sure that your eye makeup products would not cause any allergic reactions that will make the watering of your eyes worse.

Tissues always come in handy

While applying your eye makeup, it’s a good idea to keep tissues nearby. When you have watery eyes, tears are bound to let themselves out during application. It’s very important that you always have something to wipe it with.

Quality products and tools

It’s very important that you keep your tools clean and your makeup products up to date to avoid worsening your eyes’ condition. Always make sure that you don’t use anything that can cause your eyes to be more watery than it already is.

Prime the area

Whether you have watery eyes or not, it will always be a good option to prime your skin and eye area before proceeding with makeup application. Doing so will ensure that you achieve great color payoff and that the product stays on longer on your eyelids.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Watery Eyes

In the beauty and makeup industry, hundreds of eyeliners come and go. If you have watery eyes, it’s especially important that you consider specific factors to make sure you get the best for your needs.

Waterproof eyeliner

When you have watery eyes, it’s top priority that you get an eyeliner that has a waterproof formula. Waterproof liners stay intact and stay put even on watery eyes. Because the formula is waterproof, it’s able to withstand not only tears but also sweat and humidity. Make sure you get something that has been formulated to be waterproof.

Type of eyeliner

There are three types of eyeliner available in the market: liquid, pencil, and gel. It may seem like a small detail but the type of eyeliner matters. Make sure you get something you are comfortable with in applying with ease. Not all types of eyeliners are applied the same so make sure you take this into consideration.

Finish

Eyeliners also come in different finishes. They could have satin, matte, or shiny finish. Ask yourself what kind of finish would you like to achieve from your new eyeliner and make sure to get something along that preference.

Dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested

When you have sensitive eyes or watery eyes or simply just want to be on the safe side, you should keep an eye out for the terms ‘dermatologist-tested’ or ‘ophthalmologist-tested’. This assures you that the testing of the product has been overseen by a professional. This also means it’s been certified as safe for use on sensitive eyes and will not cause irritation or reactions that may worsen watery eyes.

Conclusion

If you have watery eyes, you should carefully choose the perfect eyeliner with the right formula that stays put exactly where you put it until you say it is time to go. But with so many options available, it can be confusing and that’s exactly what we’re here for!

Our number one pick for the best eyeliner for watery eyes is the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner thanks to its waterproof and all-day wearing formula even on watery eyes! The marker-like felt tip also allows you easy and precise application whether you’re going for thin and subtle or thick and bold. If what you’re looking for is an eyeliner that is able to give you intense and dramatic looks, then you better check out the Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner! This provides intense and highly-pigmented results every single time that is able to withstand watery eyes. And the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner is our choice for the best bang for your buck as it allows you to get a budget-friendly eyeliner without compromising quality results and staying power.

Eyeliners are one of the beauty products that can make you look wide awake even if you are dead tired – one of the reasons why it’s one of my favorites. If you haven’t found your go-to eyeliner just yet, we hope our guide, review, and list above have helped you in that department. Happy shopping!