Best Concealer for Eyebrows

Best Concealer for Eyebrows featured photo

If you’re on the lookout for the best concealer for eyebrows you can get your hands on right now, be sure to stop to consider a few important factors before making the final decision: the correct shade, your skin type, the concealer type, and the ingredients. I have searched far and wide and have the best I could find reviewed and summarized just below. If you’re ready to dive in on my favorites and how these factors came into play, go ahead and scroll along!

Eyebrows can help form people’s impression of you as they are very prominent features of the face. I started fixing up my brows pretty early on because I have naturally thick and bushy eyebrows. I make it a point to regularly clean them to avoid growing them back all bushy and out of shape. And I also lived through the 2000s trend of having on fleek eyebrows and I make sure mine stay on the fleek train.

Another thing I’m thinking of jumping in on are concealers for eyebrows. After watching countless makeup tutorials, I decided I’m finally ready to add them to my brow routine, especially on days I want them to be extra on fleek. To make sure I only get the best, I did intensive research on the best currently out in the market.

If you’re also looking to add one or upgrade what’s already in your routine, read on to find out what my current favorites are.

Should You Use Concealer for Your Eyebrows?

Concealers have become a favorite among makeup enthusiasts because of their ability to conceal and hide dark circles, dark spots, scars, blemishes, and other skin imperfections you might want hidden as you do the rest of your makeup.

But another great thing you can do with concealers is to sculpt, shape, and highlight your eyebrows. It can help your brows look more lifted and overall more prominent every time you do your makeup routine. Concealers, when used around the eyebrows, can also hide and conceal small and fine hairs in between waxing and plucking.

If you’re still on the edge on whether you should get one or not, think again!

Types of Concealers

Before we head on to my list of my favorite concealers you can get your hands on right now, it’s important that you are familiar with the different types of concealers available for you to choose from.

Liquid

Liquid concealers are the most common type you can see available in the market. They have a light consistency that allows users to apply and blend them with much ease. Coverage depends on the formula and finish type can vary from matte, dewy, or natural finish. This has been a favorite go-to among many but especially beginners.

Cream

Another type of concealer are cream concealers. These concealers also have thicker consistency than those of liquid concealers. They often offer medium to full coverage and effectively hide and cover blemishes and pores. When using this type of concealer, it is important that you moisturize pre-application. And because they can often crease, it’s also an important step in cream concealers to set it well with powder.

Stick

Stick concealers, as the name suggests, come in the form of sticks. They are thick and often creamy in consistency. They also offer amazing coverage that can erase and hide away blemishes and blur enlarged pores. They also leave your skin with a radiant finish that will last you for the entire day. Those who have oily skin should proceed with caution in using stick concealers though as it can be quite heavy on the face.

Our Top Picks for the Best Concealers for Eyebrows

Product ImageProduct NamePrice
Our PickAnastasia Beverly Hills Pro PencilAnastasia Beverly Hills Pro PencilCheck Price
Best BudgetL.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition ConcealerL.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition ConcealerCheck Price
Best SplurgeTarte Shape Tape Contour ConcealerTarte Shape Tape Contour ConcealerCheck Price
NYX Studio Photogenic ConcealerNYX Studio Photogenic ConcealerCheck Price
Maybelline New York Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting ConcealerMaybelline New York Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting ConcealerCheck Price

The Best Concealer for Eyebrows

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro Pencil – Our Pick!

Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro Pencil

Our top pick for the best Concealer for eyebrows out in the market right now is the Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro Pencil! A full-coverage highlighter and concealer, this pro pencil promises to define your eyebrows with every use. Every time you whip this one out as part of your makeup routine, you are sure to achieve amazing definition and highlights on your brow bone. It offers enough coverage and pigment to conceal and cover fine and short hairs around your eyebrows as well.

The precise tip of the Anastasia Beverly Hills concealer allows users to easily apply it around the eyebrows with much detail and precision. Its width and size is also the perfect size to easily cover your brow bones for the ideal amount of highlight. Though made for specific use on your brows, you can also conveniently use it along your lips, as eyeshadow base, and as concealer anywhere on your face aside around your eyebrows.

This pro pencil concealer has been formulated with full-pigment, powder-like consistency that dries down to a matte finish. It melts into the skin and is barely noticeable once it has set after application. The formula is also easy to blend as you build in more layers. It’s been praised for being a very easy and fast way of eyebrow concealer application. It currently comes in 3 shades for fair, medium, and darker skin tones.

The pencil eyebrow highlighter and concealer is proudly vegan and cruelty-free. If that is something important to you, you might want to check this one out. Every time you use this as part of your makeup and eyebrow routine, you are promised a world where your eyebrows are truly highlighted and defined. You can trust this one to really make a great difference on how you wear your eyebrows for the day.

Pros:

  • Full-coverage highlighter and concealer
  • Truly highlights and defines eyebrows
  • Conceals fine and short hairs
  • Precise tip for detailed application
  • Can be used on other areas for concealing as well
  • Full-pigment and powder-like consistency
  • Matte finish
  • Blendable formula
  • Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons:

  • Available in 3 shades only

2. L.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition Concealer – Best Budget!

L.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition Concealer

The next item that made it into our list of the best concealers for eyebrows and our pick for the best budget option is the L.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition Concealer! If what you’re looking for is an effective eyebrow concealer but at the same time something that you wouldn’t have to sacrifice your budget for, then hold on to your seat for this one. This promises to help you effectively clean the area around your brows so you achieve eyebrows on fleek for days.

Each time you use this as part of your makeup routine, you are sure to get sharp and defined eyebrows that will last you all day. The brush tip of the concealer also makes use and application much easier – even for beginners. Its consistency makes it easy to spread and blend. It also has a buildable formula that allows you to achieve coverage that’s perfect for your needs.

The full coverage formula this L.A. Girl concealer offers its users the ability to cover up and camouflage skin blemishes and imperfections you would want hidden when you apply your makeup for the day. It also promises long-wear while being light to wear all day and without any creasing at all. The concealer is currently available in 30 shades and you are positive to find the right shade for your skin tone!

Just a quick reminder that some users who have shared their experience with it have stated that the concealer can sometimes be quick to dry and therefore may prove difficult to blend. You just have to make sure that you blend it right away after application to avoid this issue.

Pros:

  • Ideal budget eyebrow concealer
  • Available in 30 shades
  • Cleans around the eyebrows
  • Sharp and defined eyebrows
  • Offers full coverage
  • Lightweight for all day wear
  • Easy to apply and blend
  • Buildable formula
  • Covers up blemishes and skin imperfections

Cons:

  • Can dry quickly after application

3. Tarte Shape Tape Contour Concealer – Best Splurge!

Tarte Shape Tape Contour Concealer

Our next favorite concealer for eyebrows and our top choice for the best splurge is the Tarte Shape Tape Contour Concealer! If you’re looking for and ready to splurge on your new eyebrows concealer, you might want to get on board with this one. This concealer offers full coverage to help you shape, define, and lift your eyebrows for days. With this in your makeup routine, you are promised full coverage for a whopping 16 hours of flawless wear.

The Tarte concealer promises to stay on all day, without fading or changes in its color. It also doesn’t rub off when you accidentally touch it on your face. The formula is also crease-proof and wouldn’t cake or settle on fine lines and wrinkles. This one adries to a matte finish and offers a variety of 35 shades for all skin tones. The concealer’s tape technology helps smooth out and blur fine lines and wrinkles with every use.

Formulated with shea butter, sunflower peony, licorice root, and vitamin E, this will not only help shape, highlight, and define your eyebrows but will also nourish and moisturize your skin. The formula is completely waterproof so you won’t have to worry about it fading when touched with water. It’s also 100% non-comedogenic, not leaving you with any worries of pore clogging.

The contour concealer has been formulated without parabens, mineral oil, phthalates, or gluten and is totally cruelty-free – so having this in your hands every time you do your makeup, you are sure you are only using the best of the best. The only downside users have shared is that this can be a bit pricey. But if you are ready to splurge on your new concealer, then you are sure that the one downside is outweighed by all the benefits you get from this.

Pros:

  • Best splurge option
  • Full coverage concealer
  • Shapes, defines, and lifts eyebrows
  • 16 hours of flawless wear
  • Crease-proof, doesn’t cake, settle, or rub off
  • Matte finish
  • Available in 35 shades
  • Nourishing and moisturizing formula
  • Waterproof and non-comedogenic
  • No harmful chemicals and cruelty-free

Cons:

  • Pricey

4. NYX Studio Photogenic Concealer

NYX Studio Photogenic Concealer

Our next favorite concealer for eyebrows is the Studio Photogenic Concealer from makeup brand NYX! Offering medium though not too full coverage, this concealer shapes, lifts, defines, and highlights your eyebrows so you get beautiful eyebrows for days. On top of defining your brows, this is also effective in covering and concealing blemishes, skin imperfections, discoloration, and dark circles so you are able to achieve much flawless makeup.

Designed with an efficient wand, this allows for easy applications on eyebrows to help you achieve the shape and definition you’re going for. The consistency of this concealer isn’t too thick at all, making it easy to apply and blend. It also doesn’t look too pasty or dry on skin and doesn’t look cakey at all. It promises all day wear without streaking or creasing throughout the day. It isn’t too oily or too dry and has a buildable coverage no matter how many layers of it you wear.

The NYX concealer is proud to not have been tested on animals so you’re sure to use every swipe with only peace of mind. It’s currently offered in 23 shades you can conveniently choose from to fit your skin tone. It’s also been formulated to be very lightweight, ensuring your comfort even for all day wear. The formula is non-comedogenic and wouldn’t cause you any clogging on pores. Overall, it offers great quality in a bottle yet remains an affordable option.

Pros:

  • Shapes, lifts, and defines eyebrows
  • Offers medium coverage
  • Effectively conceals and cover blemishes and imperfections
  • Easy application and easy to blend
  • Not too dry or too oily
  • No creasing or streaking and not cakey
  • Buildable formula
  • No animal testing
  • Non-comedogenic
  • Available in 23 shades
  • Lightweight but all day wear

Cons:

  • Not full coverage

5. Maybelline New York Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting Concealer

Maybelline New York Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting Concealer

The last item that made it into our list of the best concealers for eyebrows is the Maybelline New York’s Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting Concealer! This concealer shadows, illuminates, and highlights as it conceals the finer and shorter hairs around your eyebrows. This one promises to define and brighten your skin with every use. It’s currently available in 6 shades and you are sure to find one or a combination of some to fit your skin tone.

A highlighter and concealer in one tube, this serves as a great quick touch-up whenever you are doing your eyebrows as part of your daily makeup routine. The pen-like packaging it comes with makes it easy to use and control for application. It also glides on skin smoothly without much effort needed. It feels very light and not overly greasy, assuring comfort even for all day wear. You can also opt to use this on the corners of your eyes to give yourself a brighter, radiant, and dewy finish.

As this concealer is best worked on small spots and quick fixes, it’s not much of a heavy-duty concealer, though a great fix for your smaller areas around your eyebrows for lifting ad definition. The formula is non-comedogenic and is totally safe to use even on sensitive skin types. It’s also been dermatologist and allergy tested and promises that you only use the best on your skin.

Pros:

  • Conceals hairs around eyebrows
  • Shadows, illuminates, and highlights eyebrows
  • Available in 6 shades
  • Great for quick touch-us and fixes
  • Easy to use and control for application
  • Lightweight, non-greasy feel
  • Gives radiant and dewy look when used on corners of the eyes
  • Non-comedogenic
  • Dermatologist and allergy-tested

Cons:

  • Not heavy-duty concealer

How to Use Concealer for Eyebrows

Knowing the right steps and methods of applying an eyebrow concealer is just as important as finding the right product for you.

Use after foundation

The first thing you need to remember in terms of concealer application is that it should be applied after your foundation – always. Applying it under your foundation might cause unwanted color changes and therefore might not be as effective in sculpting and defining your brows.

Below your eyebrows

Apply your chosen concealer below your brow line. This will help define and bring attention to your brow’s arch and line and will make them more noticeable.

Clean around

After filling in your eyebrows with your favorite eyebrow pencil or powder, you can clean around them with concealer. This will give you a cleaner eyebrow finish and will make them appear even more defined, sculpted, and highlighted.

How to Choose the Best Concealer for Eyebrows

Having the right eyebrow concealer in your makeup routine will ensure you get the best results every time you whip it out to use.

Correct shade

The first thing you want to make sure you get right is your concealer’s shade. To achieve a lifted and sculpted appearance for your eyebrows, make sure to get something that’s at least two shades lighter than your skin tone.

Skin type

The next important thing you want to be considering in choosing your new eyebrow concealer is your skin type. You have to keep in mind that not all makeup products work the same across all skin types. Make sure you consider your skin type and get something that’s formulated to work best on that specific skin type.

Type of concealer

As we’ve discussed earlier, there are different types of concealers available to you: liquid, cream, and stick. Ask yourself your preferred consistency and how you would want to apply your concealer.

Your skin type could also affect the type of concealer you choose. Liquid concealers are a great choice for those with dry skin types. On the contrary, it would be good for those with oily skin types to avoid stick concealers as they can be quite heavy on skin.

Ingredients

The last thing you’d want to be looking at is the concealer’s list of ingredients. You would want to make sure you aren’t allergic to any of the ingredients and that they are only safe and clean ingredients to make sure you only get to use the best of the best.

Conclusion

Having the right concealer to sculpt, lift, and highlight your eyebrows will navigate attention to them, making them more noticeable. And if you want to make good first impressions, having such eyebrows is one way to go about it.

Our pick for the best concealer for eyebrows is the Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro Pencil for its full coverage highlighter and concealer formula that highlights and defines your brows like no other. If what you’re on the lookout for is a budget-friendly eyebrow concealer, you might want to check out L.A. Girl Pro Conceal High Definition Concealer! This does a great job at cleaning around your eyebrows and giving them a more defined shape. And the Tarte Shape Tape Contour Concealer is our choice for the best splurge on eyebrow concealers. It offers full coverage to shape, lift, and define your eyebrows and allows for all day wear!

We hope you found your new favorite concealer for eyebrows from our list and review above. Remember, the key to always on fleek eyebrows is the right concealer to give you just the right amount of definition and highlight. Happy makeup shopping!